My response to an open-minded carnist

Via Gary Smith
on Sep 8, 2011
get elephant's newsletter

(I always appreciate communicating with open minded carnists and wanted to share my response to her questions).

I appreciate your willingness to chat. I would say that most of our views about animals come from the culture that we grew up in. We have been taught that animals are lower than us and hence we can eat and use them as we like. Very few of us ever challenge this thinking because a) it asks us to challenge other views that we have about our culture and b) it asks us to question our values and ethics. Neither are necessarily easy to do.

It’s as simple as I do not need to eat any animal products, wear clothing that comes from animals, support any form of entertainment that uses animals or buy any products that come from testing on animals. Since I do not need to use animals, I have an ethical choice to make. Do I support the harming and killing of animals for my pleasure, tradition or convenience or do I make choices that are more in alignment with my values?

Very few us have values that support harming animals yet almost all of us engage in harming animals directly or indirectly. The reason that our values do not support harming animals is because at our core, we are kind beings. Why would we want to make another suffer? Why would we possibly want to inflict pain on another if we don’t have to? And of course, whether we harm individuals directly or indirectly, by paying farmers and slaughterhouse workers to do it for us, we are causing harm. This is not in our nature. We have to hide this from ourselves. We have to repress the violence that we cause others, that is why people get so upset when a vegan shares this information with them. Because we now a choice. We either continue to repress this information (which becomes more difficult) or we make a new choice. I admire your willingness to look.

Whether someone addresses this from a spiritual or religious perspective, both center on the idea of compassion. We can make compassionate choices three times a day by choosing to eat beans, legumes, grains, nuts and seeds, fruits and vegetables. I find it difficult to near impossible to believe in a God that would put creatures here for us to force breed, confine, torture and ultimately kill, when we don’t have a biological need to do so. That would not be a compassionate God.

Speciesism is what allows for all other forms of isms. If human beings believe that they are superior to another animal (since we are all animals), then it makes it easier to believe that we are superior to other races, religions, sexes, sexuality and the like. Speciesism is the the largest form of ism and also the most ignored. The industries that profit from animal exploitation are begging you to ignore me and your heart. They only survive (and sadly thrive) due to our ignorance of speciesism or our unwillingness to look. Thanks for looking.

*Courtesy of The Thinking Vegan


About Gary Smith

Gary Smith is co-founder of Evolotus, a PR agency working for a better world. Evolotus specializes in nonprofits, documentary films, animal advocacy campaigns, health/wellness, natural foods and socially beneficial companies. Gary blogs at The Thinking Vegan and writes for elephant journal, Jewish Journal, Mother Nature Network and other publications. Gary and his wife are ethical vegans and live in Sherman Oaks, CA with their cat Chloe and two beagles rescued from an animal testing laboratory, Frederick and Douglass.


2 Responses to “My response to an open-minded carnist”

  1. kefir says:

    It’s appropriate time to make a few plans for the future and it’s time to be happy. I’ve learn this submit and if I could I want to recommend you few attention-grabbing issues or advice. Maybe you can write subsequent articles referring to this article. I desire to learn more things about it!

  2. […] 1. Place the cardboard and newspaper over the area where you want to improve the soil. If you are using newspaper, make sure it is at least 10 sheets thick. If you are using cardboard, one to two sheets deep is fine. Just make sure that the edges overlap so that sunlight does not reach the soil. You might need to visit your local grocery or liquor store to get enough materials. Just avoid using colored, glossy paper because the cardboard and newspaper act as a light barrier to the weeds and weed seeds below it. They will smother the existing weeds and grass and deprive the weed seeds of the life giving forces they need to sprout. When you till an area like this, which many people like to do, you are not only disturbing the existing beneficial soil life, you are also tilling into the soil all of the weed seeds that have accumulated over the years (many seeds can lay dormant 10 years or more just waiting for the right conditions to sprout.). Over time, the cardboard and newspaper will break down, but by then, you have built enough soil over the top of the barrier that the seeds below will eventually become worm food. […]