Blurring the Line: Monogamy. ~ Zach Beach

Via Zach Beach
on Feb 26, 2014
get elephant's newsletter


Five Ways to Help Us Challenge Our Ideas of Monogamy.

When I tell people that I’m polyamorous, the typical response is a mixture of “that sounds really complicated,” and “I could never do that!”

While polyamory may seem crazy and different from monogamy in theory, in practice both poly and mono relationship styles are quite similar.

We all have people in our lives that we care deeply about.  This includes friends  (people that provide emotional and loving support), as well as partners (people which we generally reserve for things like sexual relations, intimacy, cohabitation, child-rearing and financial sharing).

This partner/friend line and the way we define, direct and distinguish the people in our lives, is essentially what separates a monogamous relationship from an open one. Just move a few more people from the “friend” category into the “partner” category and—Voilà!—here you are with multiple relationships! Your polyamory ID card should be coming in the mail in a few days.

Where this line resides and what the line means depends on the person who draws it. For monogamous couples, this line is the defining factor in what makes them monogamous. Crossing this line is deemed “cheating,” and relationships often get into trouble when one person has a different idea of where the line is than the other.

Here are five things we can consider to help us blur the monogamy line, and to challenge our ideas about monogamy overall.

1. Increase levels of physical intimacy with another person.  

We are used to putting things into “Either-Or” categories, like partner or friend, mono or poly and sexual or nonsexual, when in reality intimacy lies along an entire spectrum of experience.

For example, how do you feel about your partner and somebody else doing the following:

  • having dinner together?
  • dancing together?
  • going to see a movie together?
  • spending all night talking?
  • holding hands while walking down the street?
  • cuddling together?
  • kissing?
  • eye-gazing?
  • sleeping together (no sex, just sleeping)?
  • spending a weekend camping and hiking?
  • taking a bath or shower together?
  • having oral sex or intercourse?

Also, consider what difference it would make if you knew the person, if you knew and agreed to the activity, and if you were involved in some way with the activity.

2. Talk about sexual histories. 

Some people may not be comfortable with their partner being sexual with someone else, but what about talking and hearing about sexual encounters from previous relationships?

For example, consider asking your partner:

  • What is your favorite sexual memory from a previous relationship?
  • Did you ever have a partner do something you particularly liked or disliked?
  • What kind of concerns or worries about sex did you have in your previous relationships?

3. Talk about sexual fantasies.

Another challenging exercise for some couples is to openly discuss their sexual fantasies. While sexual fantasies come in all shapes and colors, some common ones include:

  • Fantasies with your current partner (role-play, BDSM, tantra, etc).
  • Fantasies that include more than two people (most commonly threesomes).
  • Fantasies about a specific person in real life (boss, coworker, friend, crush).

While it may be easy to hear about your partner’s desire to wear pink fuzzy handcuffs during your next romp in the bedroom, hearing your partner talk about a secret desire for a coworker might feel a bit uncomfortable. Remember that there is a difference between having a fantasy, and having a desire to play it out in real life.

4. Talk about masturbation.

While we generally think of a relationship as two people being together, we often forget about the relationship we all have with ourselves.

While almost everyone masturbates, few partners have discussed how, whywhen and where they like to masturbate. Understanding and coming to terms with your partner being sexual without you, is one step on the way to admitting the possibility that you may not be able to completely meet your partner’s sexual needs.

To add an interesting twist, consider the difference it would make if your partner masturbated while watching porn, having a live chat with another person, or engaging in phone sex/cyber sex. When does it become cheating?

5. Come clean about the affair you had, or are currently having. 

More and more researchers are finding that monogamy is actually more like monogamy in theory. Between 50-60% of both males and females report committing infidelity in a relationship. For marriages, the infidelity rate is around 40%. What makes it even more interesting is that these infidelities are not just one-night stands—the average length of an affair is two years.

Polyamorous ethics strongly hold that the fundamental difference between cheating and ethical nonmongamy, is whether or not the people involved know and have agreed to it. Also, by coming clean and actually talking about the affair, you might also come to an understanding of why the affair was committed.

So, there you have it! Talking about previous, future, fantastical, solitary and possibly current sexual activities is very close to actually doing them. Suddenly the mono/poly divide doesn’t seem so big, and their similarities blur the line of distinction created by their differences.



Love elephant and want to go steady?

Sign up for our (curated) daily and weekly newsletters!




Editorial Assistant: Brandy Mansfield/Editor: Bryonie Wise

Photo: Pixoto



About Zach Beach

Zach Beach  is a yogi, poet, writer, spiritual warrior and self-proclaimed love activist, and is currently pursuing an MA in East-West Psychology at The California Institute of Integral Studies. Check out his blog, his website, or be part of his new project, Radical Love Stories.


4 Responses to “Blurring the Line: Monogamy. ~ Zach Beach”

  1. MJoergen says:

    Nice article. Good suggestions for conversations with my partner. I'm currently – for my self – thinking about this monogamy thing. I would like to be monogamoous, and I would like my partner to remain monogamous. I'm not really interested in this polygamy thing.

    But WHY is it important to me? Why do people want their partners to be monogamous? Why do people want to CONTROL, what their partners do and with whom? It seems very illogical, as if we want to OWN our partner.

    Is it a cultural bias? I'm too young to remember the 70's with "peace, love, and understanding", but were times different then?
    Is it fear of being abandoned, fear that the partner will leave us?
    Is it fear of being jealous?
    Or is it something else?

    I would appreciate any comments on this.

  2. Tess Lauder says:


    Suggested reading: "Sex at Dawn" by Christopher Ryan and Cacilda Jetha. That book will answer a lot of your questions.

  3. Alia says:

    Great article!

    Some tidbits from my journeys in the poly world, one can still cheat in these relationships.

    I’m into full disclosure so I have had partners share intimacy and not tell me about it. I consider that cheating.

    Also, when a partner and I have agreed that a certain person is off the table and they still pursue said person, that is cheating.

    I have gotten the line, ‘it’s not cheating, you are poly’ a couple times and would like to make it clear, cheating is dishonesty and breaking agreements of any kind. It can and does happen in poly situations.

    Thanks for the read 🙂

  4. Zach says:

    Hi MJ,
    You ask some very insightful questions. It's great that you are questioning why people do the things they do.

    Human beings are extraordinarily complex, so it's difficult to say people are a certain way for specific reasons. It's true that some people might want to be in a monogamous relationship because of cultural conditioning, desire to control and own another (giving a sense of security), fear of loss, unaddressed emotional issues, as well as simple evolutionary bias to maintain one's own genetic lineage.

    However, two people may choose to be monogamous not because of any "problem" but simply because they are better off that way. One relationship style is not necessarily superior to another. Some people are simply too busy to maintain more than one relationship due to work or family. Some want a dedicated partner to raise their children with. Others may enjoy the specialness and commitment that comes with a lifelong monogamous partner.

    There are many ways to love and there is no one right way.

    From the sound of it you have thought about it and know what you want, which is great! Thanks for reading and good luck!

    PS. Polyamory is maintaining multiple intimate relationships, while polygamy is one husband with more than one wife (polyandry is one wife with more than one husband).