What does a yoga body look like? {Adult}

Via Chelsea Roff
on Apr 13, 2011
get elephant's newsletter

via Yoga Modern

The church says the body is a sin.

Science says the body is a machine.

Advertising says the body is a business.

My yoga practice says the body is ____________.

There’s been an explosion of commentary in the yoga blogosphere as of late about yoga bodies— Slim, Calm, Sexy YogaA Plea from Curvy YogisJudith Laster’s Shellacking of Naked Bodies in YJ, and the new Yoga Journal Talent Search. With the emphasis on asana practice in modern culture, it seems that Western conceptions of what a healthy body looks like have snuck their way into the yoga room as well.

A few weeks ago, I shared some truly eye-opening photos on a blog I where I serve as editor, Yoga Modern, that depict a surprising diversity of bodies in what many might expect to be a very elite and homogenous group of individuals– Olympic athletes. The pictures elicited quite a bit of discussion from readers about the conflicting messages we get about our bodies in society and in the practice room, so when I stumbled onto this piece of art I felt it too provocative to share. Unfortunately, I can’t seem to find the artist/photographer cited anywhere, but the quote is from Uruguayan writer Eduardo Galeano.

Click here for more images

Discussion around the body in yoga is certainly not unique to our time; sages have been debating the role of  the body in spiritual practice since time immemorial. Just last week at a Yoga Sutras discussion group I help facilitate, we discussed Patanjali’s concept of saucha in the Yoga Sutras:

2.40 Through cleanliness and purity of body and mind (saucha), one develops an
attitude of distancing, or disinterest towards one’s own body, and disinclined towards
contacting the bodies of others.

To be completely honest, I was a little surprised when I finally saw saucha mentioned in its original context. So often I’ve heard the yogic concept of purity/cleanliness referred to as a practice we cultivate in order to make progress in our asana practice or develop a more loving/respectful relationship with our body. I was comforted to hear from others in the group that I wasn’t the only one who was taken aback by this verse.

Patanjali almost seems to be implying here that yoga encourages us to distance ourselves from our bodies, to begin to sever the mental attachments we have to our flesh. Woah. So if yoga is all about union, bringing together body and mind, making one of opposites… what the heck is this?

Now mind you, Patanjali was writing from the perspective of the classical yoga tradition, and many believe the Tantric yogis had a significantly different attitude toward the flesh. I wonder sometimes if when we lift up these texts– or any spiritual scripture for that matter– as “sacred” or handed down from the Divine… I wonder if we realize the consequences that come from mindlessly applying them to radically different contexts. We live in a different world than the ones Patanjali, Jesus, Mohammed, and others were originally speaking to. That’s not to say that the ancient wisdom texts have no relevance for our modern world– quite the contrary in fact– but I do think it means we have to be especially vigilant about the way we interpret the teachings’ application to our current context.

What happens when a young woman who has come to her mat to begin the process of healing from sexual violence hears her teacher encouraging the class to cultivate purity  in their yoga practice? Or when a 17-year-old girl who’s trying yoga because her therapist recommended it as a way of reconnecting with her body and healing from an eating disorder hears her teacher going on about how boat pose will give her washboard abs? Have no doubt, they’re in there. The question for us, as yogis, is whether we’re willing to talk about it.

I’m passionate about shining a light and developing a dialogue around the topics that are often skirted in mainstream discourse. All too often the quiet, gentle voices asking us to look at something we’ve been missing are trumped by the hoots and hollers of angry, power-hungry dissent. So here, I’d like to create a safe space for curious reflection. Tell me, what does your yoga practice tell you about your body? What message to you get from the wider yoga community– from your teachers, from Yoga Journal, from your fellow practitioners– and does it differ from your experience on the mat? Does yoga bring you into greater connection with your body or does it make you less interested in your physical self?

I encourage the community here at Elephant Journal to share in the discussion, contribute to the dialogue, build a bridge between people and communities that may not otherwise have heard one another’s voice. We may live in different places, walk different paths, inhabit different bodies… but we’re all in this together, right?

Check out What Does a Yoga Body Look Like? Part 2 & Part 3

68,883 views

About Chelsea Roff

Chelsea Roff is a nationally-recognized author and speaker, and the Founder of Yoga for Eating Disorders. In September 2013, Chelsea raised $50,000 on the crowdfunding platform IndieGoGo to kickstart her non-profit, Yoga for Eating Disorders. The program is currently being offered in treatment centers and yoga studios around the country at no charge, and she is working with researchers at UC San Diego to evaluate the program’s effectiveness in treatment. Chelsea is known for her intelligent, inspiring, and tell-it-like-it-is speaking style, and for weaving together profound personal experiences with her scientific background to deliver deeply moving insights. After nearly losing her life to anorexia and a subsequent stroke when she was 15, she has became a national advocate for community-based mental health interventions. Her work was recently showcased by Sanjay Gupta on CNN, and she’s been keynote speaker at 92nd Street Y, The Omega Institute, and at various universities and conferences around the country. Chelsea currently lives in Venice, California, where she can be found cartwheeling across the beach, hiking in the mountains, and practicing yoga poses on her little pink scooter.

Comments

73 Responses to “What does a yoga body look like? {Adult}”

  1. […] from a link on Facebook. I checked it out and found some really cool articles, including this one, What does a yoga body look like? (warning: the link opens to an article, but the picture at the top involves […]

  2. […] recent question to the yoga community, What Does a Yoga Body Look Like? I’ve been so inspired the comments– women declaring “my curves and changes were made to create a dwelling place for my […]

  3. Rebecca says:

    Chelsea, thank you for asking the questions. Too often, we get caught up in the "right" way to be, whether we must accept our bodies as they are, or we must be thin to fit in. I find myself struggling between the two. I was really, really thin for several years, and also unhealthy (though without an eating disorder, just a thyroid issue), but as that got better, and I gained weight, and people noticed, I felt out of place – nowhere more than in the thin yoga community. I struggle with it daily. Yet, outside of weight, yoga has given me an appreciation for "the body." By that I mean that I finally am beginning to truly and deeply understand how the body and our physical selves relate to our spiritual and emotional beings. That is the union we create – within ourselves. For that, I am eternally grateful. As for the weight issue – well, as long as my pants fit, I try to keep happy.

  4. Vanita says:

    Karen,

    I love your last question.. "it is more about the mind, no?" YES! This debate generates much traffic and no small measure of judgement and anger, but after all, it is not even about the body.

  5. […] Oh wait, that’s pretty much every one of them. I like yoga. […]

  6. […] you haven’t noticed, I like to write in series (see: What Does a Yoga Body Look Like? Part 1, Part 2, & Part 3) and this post will be no different. In Part 2, I’ll respond to any […]

  7. […] always been an avid questioner, and sometimes my fiery curiosity gets me into trouble. I don’t ask questions to challenge or criticize, but sometimes I think people read it that way, and the very act of my […]

  8. […] Most likely, the teacher can’t hear your specific thoughts, per say, but rest assured they can pick up when you are thinking versus when you are completely absorbed in your breath and body awareness. […]

  9. Konnichiwa! Hannah Jinxy-chan wa utsukushii!! Ja mata ne!

  10. Correction: the church says the body is a TEMPLE. My favorite definition. In yoga, the body is the vehicle for enlightenment. Purity is misunderstood by westerners who see through a calvinist filter. All purity means is that when conditions are ripe in the body enlightenment dawns naturally.

  11. Thanks for the information. Couldn’t find this info anywhere!

  12. Hi dear!

    I really liked your text. I will have to read part 2 and 3 =).

    As a yoga teacher, what has worked for me is to talk about strengthening the "solar plexus", abs, torso (which is all the same) from the "emotional and energetic" body point of view. So before the class or while doing abs, I speak to students about what the solar plexus or abs represent in our lives: decisions, acceptance, the process of digesting life, will power… and then I speak about the roll torso has on holding oneself up, the spine, in balance, in protecting the most important organs. This way I think I can make them understand that the physical, emotional, spiritual, energetic body is all the same and that if we strengthen one, we strengthen the other. And what effects we can expect to have in life because of working on them. =)

  13. Melinda says:

    I love this topic! I am a recovering anorexic, and I fell in love with yoga while living in Thailand. The class I regularly attended was all locals,but foreigners were welcomed as well. My teachers spoke very little English, and I felt that this gave me time to listen to my body. If there was any talk about "washboard abs," I had no idea…and that's probably why I ended up loving it so much. In my mind, class was never about physical appearances, it was about personal progress and connection.

  14. Alyssa says:

    Asana practice has helped me realize that my body is not the Self, but an instrument for remembering the Self. I've had several experiences in and out of class of being everything, of knowing I am in all and all is within me eternally. There is nothing that can severe that connection. Obviously, that can't apply to the body, but to the mind.

    I find that what many consider "thinking" is really judging, which is like an aborted thought. True thought is inclusive; judgment is exclusive, and one can only believe in exclusivity in a world of bodies. Without bodies and form, outside of time, there can be no judgment. If there is no judgment, there can be no guilt, no shame and no sense of condemnation. There is only Life. True thought carries with it the certainty of freedom, while judgment is the request for condemnation and imprisonment. Forgiveness [non-judgment] is the bridge between imprisonment and freedom.

    My teachers talk about celebrating the body and "really being in your body" so that one can live more fully, be more fully present, etc. But one will only work to rectify these things if one has already judged oneself. Yoga is pause. A pause in which to question, "Is what I believe really so?" And there we have openness of mind.

    I use asana and meditation, not to enhance my body's strength or form [a learning instrument is not a goal], but to release myself and all of those within the world I perceive from the burdens of judgment. Yoga is not for the body; yoga is for refinement of the mind. This does not at all indicate that the body is bad or evil or sinful or whatnot. The body cannot be meaningfully imbued with either good or evil attributes; both are judgments. But the body can be helpful in learning that freedom comes when judgment is laid down, and that the judgment we have willfully imposed upon ourselves is far from the truth.

  15. Jinny Nash says:

    Thank you, a very interesting and timely piece as many of us are reading and writing along these lines.

    In my experience the world is full of contrast because we are and this will never change while humanity is created as it is.

    Since I attended Trauma Sensitive Yoga training I have reviewed some of my teaching language and practice and this informs how I approach every person in my class with more care in what I say and do.

    Let’s keep talking, looking at the bigger picture, not getting caught up in the details and the points of view and make yoga relevant to what we’re doing and allowing the contrast into that x

Leave a Reply