Stop Heart-Puking All Over Me!

Via elephant journal
on Aug 18, 2011
get elephant's newsletter

Photo: Dollen

It’s pretty common knowledge in yoga that heart openers can be intense and release lots of emotion – we’re always told that big backbends can be emotionally jarring, exhilarating, and difficult. However, it’s come to my attention that lots of yogis, especially teachers and experienced practitioners of Vinyasa and Anusara Yoga, have gotten a little too comfortable in backbends.

Most people need to backbend. We live in a culture of sitting and slumping over computers for hours and hours a day. We’re also a culture riddled with body insecurities, relationship dysfunction, unhealthy media influences, and other factors that would cause the common person to roll their shoulder-heads in to protect their heart.

Photo: lululemon athletica

The Anahata Chakra (the Heart Chakra) is an extremely important chakra in the body. It’s the cross-piece of most of the energy in the body: the point where liberating energy, manifesting energy, giving energy, and receiving energy all come together, and the area where precious life-force is assimilated into the body through the lungs.

So what if you do nothing but backbends all day long? You open the Anahata Chakra (and the Vishuddha Chakra – Throat Chakra) and you also open the muscles in the front line of the body and around the spine so much that it’s not much of a challenge anymore. You could sleep in Kapotasana if you felt like it. Then the heart-puking begins…

Have you seen those yogis who walk around jetting their hearts out and rolling their shoulders back as much as possible? This is a heart-puke. It’s normally accompanied by lots of Rumi quotes and poetic expressions that sound a little too memorized for my tastes. As a fairly grounded, dry Ashtangi, heart-puke is the antithesis of my personal practice. I teach and practice mostly Mysore Ashtanga, and while there are some backbends in the Finishing Series and the end of the Primary Series, it’s a lot of forward folds (Primary Series) and hip openers (Intermediate Series). There’s also no talking by the instructor (which I personally love – the overly chatty, flowery, poetic teachers just aren’t for me). So when I finally go to a Vinyasa or Anusara class, the backbends feel amazing and opening, but the heart-puking in the room gets a little too much.

My specialty as the owner of Urban Village Healeris Psychosomatic Yoga Therapy and Ayurveda (psycho = mind, soma = body). As a body-worker, I see lots and lots of different bodies, postures, and patterns of emotional holding. Most people have very closed hearts, but the few heart-puking yogis that come in to my clinic surprisingly have just as much heart center baggage as their less flexible counterparts.

Photo: Barry Silver

In Psychosomatic Postural Reading, there are several ways to identify when one is guarding one’s self. A very common way is to protect the core and chest area by slumping the posture, rolling the shoulders in, and keeping the arms close into the body or crossed along the chest. However, equally as guarded is the heart-puking yogi, who thrusts their heart and solar plexus forward and rolls their shoulders back to an extreme, which often acts as a subconscious wall or an aggressive barrier (similar to animals who puff up their chest as a sign of aggression or protection). It also causes the scapula to squeeze together and the muscles in the back of the heart to tense and get tight.

Don’t forget that Chakras don’t just live in the front of the body. What about the back of the heart center (between the shoulder blades)? If we constantly practice huge backbends, that area and the energy lines around it will become congested and blocked. Have you ever had a heart-opening moment in Paschimottanasana? If you haven’t, try rolling your shoulder blades down and open the back of the heart. It can be just as vulnerable as the front line. You can practice heart openers in backbends as well as forward bends and side bends.

So the moral of the story: we all know you love wheel, camel, and other fun backbends (trust me, we can tell), but please keep your body balanced with other important postures and keep the heart-puke to yourself. Too much of a good thing ceases to be a good thing.


Alexander Webster is an Ashtanga Yoga & Restorative Yoga teacher; the founder/owner of Urban Village Healer in the Denver Highlands (a grassroots Chinese Medicine and Ayurvedic Medicine clinic), a therapist specializing in Yoga Therapy, Ayurveda, Thai Yoga Massage, Reiki, and Chinese Medicine. He is also a Hindu Studies speaker for several colleges & universities across the United States. Alik has a Political Journalism background with The Washington Post, Politico, and MSNBC, and is currently a freelance Digital Marketing consultant specializing in non-profit marketing, website design, copywriting, and public relations. In his free time Alik is an avid marathon runner, triathlete, cyclist, rock climber, and vegan foodie.


About elephant journal

elephant journal is dedicated to "bringing together those working (and playing) to create enlightened society." We're about anything that helps us to live a good life that's also good for others, and our planet. >>> Founded as a print magazine in 2002, we went national in 2005 and then (because mainstream magazine distribution is wildly inefficient from an eco-responsible point of view) transitioned online in 2009. >>> elephant's been named to 30 top new media lists, and was voted #1 in the US on twitter's Shorty Awards for #green content...two years running. >>> Get involved: > Subscribe to our free Best of the Week e-newsletter. > Follow us on Twitter. Fan us on Facebook. > Write: send article or query. > Advertise. > Pay for what you read, help indie journalism survive and thrive—and get your name/business/fave non-profit on every page of Questions? Send to [email protected]


11 Responses to “Stop Heart-Puking All Over Me!”

  1. Tanya Lee Markul says:

    Thanks Alik!!

    Posting to Elephant Yoga on Facebook and Twitter.

    Tanya Lee Markul, Yoga Editor
    Join us! Like Elephant Yoga on Facebook
    Follow on Twitter

  2. Monica says:

    Wow, writing an article without being fully informed takes courage, but not a lot of heart…:) I think judging a whole system of yoga based on one or two classes is bad enough, but writing about it and using a word like puking really says a lot more about you and your ignorance, or maybe just self righteousness, than about anything else… I look foward to the day yogis stop comparing and criticizing, and really practice yoga, uniting and connecting whith all…

  3. erin says:

    this article seems quite judgemental. live and let live. non-judgement and acceptance, isn’t that what its all about?

  4. Terry Burke says:

    I didn't see this as being judgmental so much as a reminder to stay balanced in the body. When I practice, I always go for the poses that are easy to me, and I don't always practice poses that counter them. Thanks for the great reminder!

  5. NotSoSure says:

    Monica-You look forward to a day yogis stop comparing and criticizing but yet you use an ad hominem attack ( calling the author ignorant and self-righteous") in your response. Irony, much?

  6. Andy says:

    "There’s also no talking by the instructor (which I personally love – the overly chatty, flowery, poetic teachers just aren’t for me). So when I finally go to a Vinyasa or Anusara class, the backbends feel amazing and opening, but the heart-puking in the room gets a little too much."

    Thank you for reminding me that there is an alternative to the overly – talkative yoga teacher. Thank God.

  7. Aimee says:

    I tend to agree with Andy and Alik. That line strikes a cord with me. While the talk is sometimes uplifting and great at times, i feel like I can really get into a breath-focused moving meditation with the minimal talking Ashtanga style and really be in the practice.

  8. Mirah says:

    This sounds just like Patsy Rodenburg's "circles."

    "Heart-pukers" are in "third circle." Chests are out, voices a bit too loud, trying a bit too hard, but still not truly present and in the moment.

  9. Rj Dollen says:

    Thanks for giving me credit on the image. Very appreciated! — Dollen

  10. […] with hips out of alignment and weight not centred over the heels. (For more on heart puking, see here). I had to stop myself from being the obnoxious student and correcting the […]

  11. This guy is a fraud! says:

    He is not registered with yoga alliance = not an ERYT! Not an RTT not certified in massage therapy and it is illegal to practice and type of massage (Thai yoga massage) in the state of Colorado with out registering with DORA!