Great Doubt = Great Faith.

Via David Garrigues
on Jul 9, 2012
get elephant's newsletter
Mysore, India
David Garrigues in the Hanuman Temple on Chamundi Hill

Filling and Refilling Yoga’s Five Jars (Or Qualities to Cultivate for Progress in Practice)

Prajna—Awakening of wisdom or insight

Found in Yoga Sutra 1-20, this unique combination of qualities are meant to be cultivated and are the gifts of your practice. They can be thought of as five jars that you want to fill and keep filling. Note that these jars can be difficult to fill, can easily become depleted, the contents can get used up without your noticing, and you can also easily neglect to fill them back up.

Each person will have a different relationship to the qualities and jars. Sometimes one or two of the jars will seem very large compared to the others. These larger jars will be easier to fill up, easier to keep a ready supply of, and will take longer to deplete. Other jars will be very small, difficult to fill, hard to keep stocked and to replenish. It can be challenging to get an accurate sense of exactly what your relationship to each one is at a given time.

For example, do I have a big jar of faith that is easy to re-fill and how much faith (vs. doubt) about spirituality and/or my individual path do I really have? How easy is it for me to trust the inner work I’m doing and trust that this personal work is connected to something important, something larger than my ego, something that will lead to healing and wisdom within me and extend to the world around me? The difference between what I believe consciously and what I believe unconsciously might make accurate awareness elusive and therefore thwart my sincere attempts to acquire any given quality.

To make an accurate assessment about my ready supply of these five qualities, I need to be able to observe myself carefully and without judgement. If I struggle with doubt often, then I need to know that about myself. I need to know that the faith jar will be challenging to fill up and might get depleted easily. But the tricky part is I may also not feel ready to fully face and accept my small doubts nor my large doubts.

Here’s a little story that illustrates some of my struggles with faith vs. doubt.

Recently I was really chewing on the idea of faith in practice. I felt sorry for a student of mine who is very rational and very skeptical of anything he can’t see. He asked me if he can keep practicing if he doesn’t buy into any of the Hindu underpinnings that are present in yoga. He dismisses reincarnation, God, prayer, and approaches his study from a perspective of philosophical inquiry with its high regard for skepticism and reliance on rational thought.

But it’s not as simple as that because he also doesn’t at all feel like practice is merely physical and finds the idea of practice as a glorified gym workout singularly distasteful. He states plainly that he doesn’t do yoga for merely physical reasons. Listening to his struggle, I felt so blessed for my seemingly apparent ease with faith. I thought that somehow there’s part of me that simply “knows” that there is a purpose each of us has to fulfill—that our consciousness is meant to be used for realizing the “truth” or “goodness” of everything, of the Source. I thought I was done considering the possibility of, “What if I believe there is nothing inherently spiritual about people or things? What if I deeply question whether there is any purpose, any grand truth? What if this is all random, meaningless, and there is no ultimate realization or meaning or something that existence is leading to?”

I was mulling all this over when I saw a low-budget sign in front of a fire station. This sign had removable letters so that the firemen could post different messages frequently to keep passersbys interested. The message on this day read:

Small Doubt Small Faith
Great Doubt Great Faith

Wow! Revelation—faith does not mean blind faith, easy faith. This caused me to really look within, to see the small ways that I lack faith, to see how frequently and largely I doubt both spirituality in a collective sense and my own personal relationship to my faith. When I really dig down inside, I see that faith is something I have wrestled out of my doubt—one practice at a time—something I’ve agonized over and continue to agonize over especially when it’s time to apply my faith.

When you look within, I imagine you’ll find your supply of faith is contained in a jar you lovingly fill as you pour energy, unstintingly into your practice. It’s a freeing and powerful realization that having doubt, large or small, is not necessarily a sign of a lack of faith. It could be quite the reverse—and that could explain why my student so clearly knows that practice is so much more than physical, and yet, he is not going to pray to Ganesh or take a set of beliefs such as those of reincarnation that don’t fit for him.

Furthermore, when you really consider your practice and your relationship to any of these five qualities, you will likely see that, in the long-term, none of these jars are easy to fill, nor to keep filled. If you think one of them comes easily, it may behoove you to look again, and see if there is more depth to explore.

Each quality has to be artfully chiseled as a stone mason does when she patiently, one hammer stroke at a time, fashions a figure out of stone. Your ability to meditate (samadhi), to become entirely mentally absorbed in what is unfolding within you will be hewn painstakingly out of your practice. Prajna-wisdom, born from deep within your body, will also come hard-won from your practice. Indeed you fashion your energy, insight, faith, concentration, and your memory out of the long string of daily practices performed lovingly with great patience and care.

Mysore, India
David Garrigues at the Shiva temple on Chamundi Hill

In closing, here’s a little poem that speaks to the challenge of filling and refilling the jars:

How soon do you forget what you just learned in practice? Almost immediately.
How soon does doubt replace faith? Almost immediately.
How soon is meditation replaced by distraction and scatteredness? Almost immediately.
How soon is the bright fire you kindled during practice diminished to a faint glow in the hearth? Almost immediately.
How soon is the wisdom you gain, even the deep wisdom covered by ignorance?                         Almost immediately.

There it is, But
I and you begin again
Almost Immediately.


Editor: Brianna Bemel


Like elephant Spirituality on Facebook.


About David Garrigues

David Garrigues is an international yoga teacher. He is recognized as one of a few teachers in the US certified to teach Ashtanga Yoga by the late world renown yoga master Sri K Pattabhi Jois. As an Ashtanga Ambassador he bases his teachings on the idea that 'Anyone can take practice', a core idea in the teachings of Sri K Pattabhi Jois. David's mission is to help others flourish within the living, contemporary lineage of Ashtanga Yoga. He aims to be part of an ever wider circle of people who are committed to applying the teachings of ashtanga yoga in ways that promote physical, psychological, and spiritual growth in themselves and others. David's website and highly popular youtube video channel, Asana Kitchen, has a wealth of free, expert yoga instructional materials to inspire progress in beginner through advanced practitioners. He is the author of three Ashtanga Yoga dvd's, A Guide to the Primary Series, A Guide to the Ashtanga Yoga Pranayama Sequence, and A Guide to the Second Series. His book Vayu Siddhi: A Guide to Free Breathing was written and inspired by yogic sacred texts on the science of asana and pranayama, the two favorite subjects of students of ashtanga yoga. He is the director of the Ashtanga Yoga School of Philadelphia and the Ashtanga Yoga School of Kovalam in India.


13 Responses to “Great Doubt = Great Faith.”

  1. Thaddeus1 says:

    "When I really dig down inside, I see that faith is something I have wrestled out of my doubt—one practice at a time—something I’ve agonized over and continue to agonize over especially when it’s time to apply my faith."

    I love this simply because it shows that faith is not something that exists only in the ethers of unconsciousness, but that one can approach it is as conscious orientation towards life. That it can be cultivated, and as you so rightly point out, every day we step on our mats.

    Thank you for offering this insight.

    Posting to Elephant Ashtanga. Be sure to Like Elephant Ashtanga on Facebook.

  2. Andy says:

    I have become a big fan of the Garrigues

  3. Great article, thank you for writing and sharing. My grandmother was a devout Christian, and the one thing I learned from her, was faith. I have been thinking a lot about her and how her daily practice of faith was relentless. She never gave up no matter how troublesome her life became, and utilized faith on a daily basis as a constant spiritual practice to navigate life. It was inspiring. I appreciate this discussion of faith and doubt from the yogic perspective. Great insights.

  4. cathywaveyoga says:

    These are important words again and again to be articllated to regular people.. not just yoga practitioners. Some may feel that great doubt may remove them from connection and thus, faith, due to greatness or immensity of doubt.

  5. sheila solis says:

    I do appreciate your essays, David! What a wonderful way to put together another of life's truths…on a message board outside the fire station. I do agree. I think as an agnostic much of my life, I viewed "faith" as something other people had in "their" religions. Quite the contrary for many of the faithful I know. They, like myself have cultivated their faith through life's experiences…their own questions…their own doubts!
    One's own doubt can get one thinking critically– as only one own's doubt can …leading to understandings, connections, disconnections, etc. Faith–understanding what you are doing and being GOOD with it, can potentially percolate through these experiences…and along with your other 4 jars, help one to move deeper in their practice, their life…
    If you practice yoga regularly, I can't imagine faith is not a part of you–just that faith is such a loaded WORD that people don't embrace it as such…hope to see you again soon david!

  6. […] Faith then, is placing trust in your self—knowing that the fruits of the spiritual way will manifest as you continue to deepen. It is also trust grounded deeply in the mystery within the wilderness of the universe. […]

  7. […] had counted on it. He had wanted it. He had stayed up late chasing it, and had looked for it in every movement of the […]

  8. […] You’re being asked to jump into a deep pit. Not only is there no net, but you know there’s no net. No net will appear. In order for there to be faith, it has to be a matter of indifference to you if you will be saved or fall. You can’t, in other words, believe a net will appear (that’s a leap of faith—you already have it) you have to leap even if you don’t believe. […]

  9. […] The main point that I am constantly reminded of is that life is not on my own clock. Ultimately, it will do with me as it pleases. I can cry, kick and scream, but all of those actions are exercises in futility. They just amplify whatever I’m not being patient and accepting of, until I stop in submission. […]

  10. […] out what inspires you and follow it. Maybe it’s a style of physical practice, maybe it’s the inspirational words of a particular […]

  11. […] do a lot of interesting things when their cherished beliefs are challenged. They might start a war, gossip, grab their metaphorical or literal guns, laugh, walk away, yell, […]

  12. […] But my bio is wrong. And as much as I write about faith, it’s surprising how much I lack. […]