Sustainable Sushi? Who cares. ~ Elleni Cladis [April Fool’s Day edition]

Via elephant journal
on Apr 1, 2013
get elephant's newsletter

Great Egret with Fish

Ok so here’s the deal.

By default, I have become the elephant’s “go-to-girl” on all things sushi and fishy in the realm of sustainability and eco-responsibility. Perhaps you’ve seen my articles; perhaps not. If you haven’t, though, I highly suggest you take a look – they’re good for your sole (sic).

I’ve written about the #1 question on everyone’s mind:  whether sushi should or shouldn’t be considered a sustainable eating activity (view full article); remedies to the emotionally damaging knowledge of eating fish that are globally being overfished at alarming rates (view full article); and the silly business of mindless oyster consumption (view full article).

How did I become the fish girl? Funny story, actually.  At my first lunch with the elephant group as an incoming intern, we had sushi.  With my eyes wide shut, I was super-excited, giddy even, as I’m pretty much obsessed with sushi.  I ordered a couple of rolls with multiple types of fish in them, got my soy sauce bowl and chopsticks ready, and started to chow down.

And that’s when I made the most unfortunate, fateful mistake of looking up.

Because when I looked up, there was Waylon’s face with an odd sort of grin waiting for me.

Waylon:  “So do you like supporting mindless overfishing and the fact that it’s causing hundreds of fish species to become extinct, leaving our children and grandchildren in a world without those types of fish? As well as the business and processes of shipping fish across the world, which is one of the most anti eco-responsible acts around?”

Me:  “Umm, no,” I mumble while scarfing down another piece of yellowfin tuna.

Waylon:  “Do some research and write an article about it.  You might learn some things that will change your mind about what you order.”

Me:  “Ok.”

And I wrote the article, and I reported back from that day forward I would be self-conscious about supporting any mindless fish-murdering establishments because I care about the environment and about the little fishies.

But, the truth is, I don’t care.

Let me repeat that:  I really don’t care.  And neither should you.

If you go to a restaurant and you want to order the salmon, order the damn salmon!

Why should you have to suffer through not eating an absolutely delicious fish just because it’s on some endangered species list?  Your personal enjoyment is so much more important than the life of a silly relative of Nemo’s – if fish had any brains at all, they would not have been caught in the first place.  It’s the law of the jungle; survival of the fittest.  Please repeat after me:  “I am more important than a fish.  I am number one and I deserve the best no matter the cost.”

I’m not afraid to admit it: salmon is my favorite fish and I will continue to eat it and sleep well at night.  Tuna is another favorite of mine – do I have mercury poison concerns?  Heck no – I’ve been eating tuna since I was little and look how I turned out.  That’s right.  I’m the fish girl!

You may be wondering, “What about that fish app you wrote about? The one that tells you what fish are eco-friendly to eat?”  Read my lips:


Not everyone in the world has an iPhone (which only people with iPhone’s think) and there’s no way I’m going to carry out a little handbook every time I eat fish – let’s be real.  It’s just not going to happen.  I make my fish selection based on what works best for me.  Sometimes I’m definitely in the mood for halibut, other times, swordfish.  It really just depends on what I’ve got a taste for.

I know another issue is the fact that we’re landlocked, yet we have Chilean sea bass and Atlantic salmon on the menus at restaurants – is it our fault that we live in a landlocked state?  I mean, how many different ways can we have trout?

According to Shakespeare, “Trout by any other name still is trout.” Thanks to the shipping of fish across the world, we are able to have choices, which is always a good thing, and variety is the spice of life. Girls, especially fish girls, always like to have options!

This variety of choices is a tribute to one of the greatest practices of modern civilization: the importing and exporting of goods.  This keeps the world economy thriving and allows for globalization, breaking down boundaries, and sharing with one another.  Tell me, what the heck is wrong with that?

This may seem a little harsh to some, but remember, it’s all about Numero Uno.

Forget fish sustainability; eat sushi and be happy.


About elephant journal

elephant journal is dedicated to "bringing together those working (and playing) to create enlightened society." We're about anything that helps us to live a good life that's also good for others, and our planet. >>> Founded as a print magazine in 2002, we went national in 2005 and then (because mainstream magazine distribution is wildly inefficient from an eco-responsible point of view) transitioned online in 2009. >>> elephant's been named to 30 top new media lists, and was voted #1 in the US on twitter's Shorty Awards for #green content...two years running. >>> Get involved: > Subscribe to our free Best of the Week e-newsletter. > Follow us on Twitter Fan us on Facebook. > Write: send article or query. > Advertise. > Pay for what you read, help indie journalism survive and thrive.


11 Responses to “Sustainable Sushi? Who cares. ~ Elleni Cladis [April Fool’s Day edition]”

  1. Jen Bannister says:

    All I know after living in Asia for the past year and a half is that there are a lot of dead fish sitting on ice here….and they are looking smaller and smaller……I love sushi and only grew guilty about eating them recently….I go to sushi restuarants and markets where fish are displayed….and think….this is where the inhabitants of the oceans are laid to rest. I felt better at home (U.S) about eating sustainably raised meat than I do about eating the last of the fish living in the ocean…I don't know what to do about it, but, it seems like if we humans keep taking the finite amount of fish out of the oceans at the rate we are, the fish will lose the race against life. There're less of them than there are of us……

  2. It's April Fool's, don't worry!

  3. Emily says:

    Oh, oh, oh…phew!!! Good one, you got me!

  4. holly troy says:


  5. Rodrigo says:

    This is a very interesting article, at first I did not realize that today is April Fool's Day. After this dawned on me I realized that you posess a very subtle and fine tuned sense of humor. Congratulations on a hysterical article, I enjoyed this very much and wanted to say good job.

  6. Roni says:

    There IS sustainable fish, though. Great lecture by Dan Barber here:

  7. Analiese says:

    I was getting pretty steamed there for a minute, but thankfully realized it was satire by the end. Good one!

  8. […] Israeli research team, in collaboration with other teams across Europe, believes it has found the key to the tuna’s survival: domesticated breeding in the […]

  9. […] Israeli research team, in collaboration with other teams across Europe, believes it has found the key to the tuna’s survival: domesticated breeding in the […]

  10. […] Israeli research team, in collaboration with other teams across Europe, believes it has found the key to the tuna’s survival: domesticated breeding in the […]