5.2
April 21, 2014

Evolutionary Theory & the Incarnations of Vishnu. ~ Steven J. Rosen (Satyaraja Dasa)

Vishnu 2

Who would imagine that there could be any connection between modern evolutionary theory—which is in the domain of science—and something as esoteric as the incarnations of Vishnu—which is a central theme in the Hindu religion?

And yet science and spirituality do overlap in numerous ways, and great sages of the latter-day Vaishnava tradition have shown how the manifestations of God, so well known in India, do indeed shine light on what modern science has come to call evolutionary theory.

Although there are unlimited manifestations of the divine, the ancient Vaishnava tradition of India singles out ten as representative of the rest. These ten are known in Sanskrit as “Dashavatara.” The prefix dasha means “ten,” and avatara means “descent,” from the Sanskrit ava (“down”) and tarati (“[he] crosses over”).

Jayadeva Goswami’s 12th-century list of ten is arguably the most popular, but there are several Dashavatara lists in the Vaishnava tradition. Significant are those left to us by Vedanta Deshika (14th century) and Vadiraja Tirtha (16th century). There are few variants in these lists, and the last of these three is sometimes considered the standard: Matsya, Kurma, Varaha, Narasimha, Vamana, Parasurama, Dasarathi Rama, Krishna, Buddha, and Kalki.

Evolutionary Theory

A surprising and much documented aspect of the Dashavatara story is its connection with evolutionary theory. For those who don’t know, biological evolution is the slow process of change that is said to occur in living organisms, adapting to new environments over billions of years. Evolutionists claim that we all arise from a single common ancestor, and like the branches of a tree, species separate from each other over time—even if growing from the same tree.

Interestingly, Charles Darwin (1809–1882), the first major proponent of this theory, was foreshadowed by the Puranas of ancient India, which had already proffered a teaching of evolution. But rather than claiming that one species evolves into the next, the Puranas tell us that all species were created simultaneously, and that each eternal living being evolves through the various species until it reaches perfection. In other words, the original theory involved an evolution in consciousness.

Explaining this Puranic point of view, His Divine Grace A. C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada (1896–1977) writes as follows:

It is confirmed in Padma Purana that the species of life evolved from aquatics to plants, vegetables, trees; thereafter insects, reptiles, flies, birds, then beasts, and then human kind. This is the gradual process of evolution of species of life. . . . But we do not accept Darwin’s theory. According to Darwin’s theory, homo sapiens came later on, but we see that the most intelligent personality, Brahma, is born first. So according to Vedic knowledge, Darwin or similar mental speculators are rejected so far as the facts are concerned.[1]

Prabhupada’s point is augmented by his disciple Richard L. Thompson (Sadaputa Dasa, 1947–2008), who received a PhD in mathematics from Cornell University:

The Padma Purana provides an example of the idea of evolving consciousness. This traditional text posits a gradual evolution of souls by transmigration through 8,400,000 different forms of life. This process is generally progressive, although reversals are admitted. Remarkably, the evolutionary succession is given as aquatics, plants, insects and reptiles, birds, beasts, and human beings…this parallels the paleontological succession of marine life, terrestrial plants, insects and amphibians, reptiles, birds, advanced mammals, and finally humans. The parallelism is so close that the modern Vaishnava teacher Bhakivedanta Swami Prabhupada saw the Padma Purana as anticipating Darwin’s theory of evolution.[2]

How does all of this relate to Dashavatara?

Evolutionary theory, when viewed from a certain perspective, neatly intersects with the ten incarnations. Man’s origins in the waters is evoked by the pisciform nature of Matsya. Then come the tortoise and the boar, taking us from amphibians to land animals. This is followed by a therianthropic form (Narasimha), and then homo sapiens proper, and so on.[3]

Eventually we arrive at humans endowed with wealth, values, and spiritual knowledge. In fact, numerous Hindu teachers—and some from the West as well—have noted the correlation.

Avataric Evolutionism

C. Mackenzie Brown, Professor of Religion at Trinity University, Texas, writes prodigiously about “avataric evolutionism”—the idea that Vishnu’s ten incarnations anticipated Darwinian evolution. According to Brown, “the late nineteenth-century origins of the theory [are to be found] in the works of Keshub Chunder Sen and Madame Blavatsky.” He also cites Narayana Bhavanrao Pavgee, known as one of the “Vedic fathers of geology,” and Aurobindo Ghose, Indian nationalist turned philosopher, as early proponents of the idea.[4]

In Vaishnava circles, Bhaktivinoda Thakur (1838–1914), the Bengali reformer and devotional exemplar of the Gaudiya tradition (who was in fact one of Keshub Chunder Sen’s schoolmates) was the first to align avataras with evolution, as can be seen in his book, Sri Krishna-samhita (Chapter Three, Verses 1-11).[5] Bhaktivinoda’s thoughts on the subject were elucidated by his son and successor, Bhaktisiddhanta Sarasvati Thakur (1874–1937) as follows:

We can notice the different stages of animal life from the invertebrates to the fully-grown human beings. These stages have been classified by the Indian sages of a scientific outlook in ten orders, viz, (1) the invertebrate, (2) testaceous or shelly, (3) vertebrate, (4) erectly vertebrate (as in the combined form of man and beast), (5) mannikin, (6) barbaric, (7) civilised, (8) wise, (9) ultra-wise and (10) destructive. These are the historical stages of jivas [souls]. According to the gradation of these stages as indications of evolution of the serving mood of the jiva soul, there are manifested the ten Incarnations of God, viz., Matsya (fish), Kurma (Turtle), Varaha (Boar), Nrishmha (Man-Lion), Vamana (Dwarf), Parasu-rama, Rama, Krishna, Buddha and Kalki, as worshippable Deities with eternal transcendental Names, Forms, Attributes and Sports.[6]

To be clear, the Vaishnavas do not accept evolutionary theory as it is commonly understood. They agree that initially the earth was covered with water, and that then gradually with the emergence of land new species manifest themselves. But the species are not “created” at that time, even if the bodies gradually arise according to necessity.

As Prabhupada says, “The species already exist, and the living entity simply transfers himself from one womb to the next, just as a man transfers himself from one apartment to another. Suppose a person comes from a lower-class apartment to a first-class apartment. The person is the same, but now, according to his capacity for payment—according to his karma—he is able to occupy a higher-class apartment. Evolution does not mean physical development, but development of consciousness.”[7]

In other words, the species are created to accommodate different levels of consciousness. Living beings are placed in appropriate bodies according to their awareness level and evolve upwards or downwards according to their activities and mental disposition. That is to say, the species are static, but the evolution or devolution of consciousness is dynamic. The reason for the 8,400,000 forms of life is to accommodate all the possible forms of consciousness that develop in the course of samsara, or repeated birth and death.

Conclusion

Thus, the teachings of Vaishnavism, even though sometimes framed in terms of evolutionary discourse, as seen above, is distinct from the modern scientific perspective, stressing evolution of consciousness and not the emergence of bodies or species arising from each other.

Instead, Vaishnavism teaches that one transmigrates through the species according to an inner development (or regression) of consciousness, not through a bio-physical evolution. The Lord, in His compassion, then incarnates in these species as well, just to sanctify all life-forms for the purpose of spiritual elevation—this is the esoteric meaning of Dashavatara in a nutshell.

***

Sources:

[1] The specific quote found here is from Swami Prabhupada’s letter to his disciple Hayagriva Dasa (Los Angeles 9 March, 1970)  available at http://krishna.org/we-accept-evolution-but-not-darwins-theory/ (Accessed February 20, 2014).
[2] See Richard L. Thompson, Maya: The World as Virtual Reality (Alachua, Florida: Govardhan Hill Publishing, 2003), p. 254.
[3]  Although Dashavatara is sometimes presented in terms of evolution, the Puranas inform us that, at the dawn of cosmic creation, the fish incarnation was not alone, but rather He was accompanied by humans, plants, animals, sages, the Vedas, and so on, making this theory incompatible with the understanding of evolution as we know it today.
[4] See C. Mackenzie Brown , “The Western Roots of Avataric Evolutionism in Colonial India.” Zygon 42:2 (June 2007): 423-47. Also see C. Mackenzie Brown, “Colonial and Post-Colonial Elaborations of Avataric Evolutionism.” Zygon 42:2 (September 2007): 715-47.
[5] See Bhaktivinoda Thakura, Sri Krsna-samhita, trans., Bhumipati Dasa (New Delhi: Vrajraj Press, 1998), pp. 87-89. The book was originally published in 1880, making Bhaktivinoda’s articulation of the theory contemporaneous with that of the Theosophists and Keshub Cunder Sen, often seen as its originators. Others associate the idea with the famous scientist J. B. S. Haldane (1892–1964), but he would have expressed his notions about the subject a little later than the others, and, besides, as of the writing of this article I could not find any substantial evidence indicating that he wrote about it at all.
[6] This expression of Dashavatara in relation to evolution comes from a conversation between Bhaktisiddhanta Sarasvati Thakur and Albert E. Suthers (1887–1984), who was affiliated with the history of religions department at Ohio Wesleyan University. Their discussion originally appeared in the January 1929 issue of The Harmonist (Sree Sajjanatoshani). See Rupa Vilasa Dasa, A Ray of Vishnu (Washington, Ms., New Jaipur Press, 1988), p. 99.
[7] See “Srila Prabhupada on Darwinian Evolution.” http://iskcontimes.com/srila-prabhupada-on-darwinian-evolution (Accessed on February 22, 2014).

 

Love elephant and want to go steady?

Sign up for our (curated) daily and weekly newsletters!

Apprentice Editor: Brandie Smith/Editor: Jenna Penielle Lyons

Photo: Sudipto Bhaumik / Pixoto

Steven J. Rosen (Satyaraja Dasa)

Read 16 Comments and Reply