Are We Ready for a Slow Yoga Movement? ~ Dr. Gregg D. Winston

Via Dr. Gregg D. Winston
on Sep 15, 2014
get elephant's newsletter

Nikto Shlavic/Flickr

I’m enjoying a staycation this week, so I decided to go try a vinyasa class at a local studio that I have never visited before.

The class was taught by a young and fit looking woman. As we approached the end of the class I wondered if she would ask me how I liked her class, since It was the first time I’d taken a class at this studio.

As a matter of fact she didn’t ask me for any feedback, but told me she hoped to see me again. If she had asked how I liked her class, I would have responded with something like this:

Imagine you go out for dinner at a fine dining establishment.

This restaurant serves your favorite cuisine, and is getting rave reviews from patrons and critics alike. You have been looking forward to trying the place ever since you first heard about it.

As you drive over, you imagine everything about the experience you are about to have, from the cool atmosphere, to reviewing from the menu, but most of all how you will mindfully savor each and every bite of food, involving all your senses to maximize the experience.

After all, you think, such a meal does not come cheap.

You arrive at the restaurant, are seated, and are leisurely studying the menu, trying to decide which of the delights you will have. Not surprisingly, the restaurant is very busy, and you can tell the server is becoming impatient with your review of the menu.

So you choose something quickly.

Now, the moment you’ve been waiting for ­ the first appetizer course arrives. You gaze on the beautifully presented morsels. You inhale the fragrant aroma. Now you carefully balance that first bite on your fork and are about to lift it to your mouth, when the server strides up to the table, swoops down and takes your appetizer away, replacing it with the salad course.

With each course, this same pattern is repeated.

By the end of the meal you cannot even remember why you wanted to go to this particular restaurant.

Just to provide you, my reader, with a some context, let me tell you a little bit about myself. I have been practicing yoga, Tai Chi, and zazen for 35 years. I have taught all of the above on and off, but never as my primary occupation.

These days my practice is primarily a daily home affair, but I do have a few private students and classes which I teach each week. I also attend a weekly yoga class that is oriented toward beginning students, but allows me the freedom to work on more advanced variations if I like.

The reason I like attending and teaching beginners’ classes is because we take more time in each asana. And here is where slow yoga comes in. When I started in yoga all those years ago, the only brand­ name yoga styles I can remember were Sivananda, Kripalu, and Iyengar. At that time I had never heard of Ashtanga (except from Patanjali), Vinyasa, Power, Yin, etc. But all the folks I knew that practiced at that time seemed to hold each posture for at least eight to 10 slow breaths, or longer. Even in our sun salutations we held each posture.

This morning’s class just felt rushed to me. Before I was able to really sink into any one of the asanas, we were already moving on to the next, and the next, and the next after that.

Now don’t get me wrong—I admire the dedication and skill it takes to move quickly through an advanced flow. I also admire dance, gymnastics, and martial arts. Personally, I like to keep things distinct.

So for aerobic exercise, I will go out on a nice run.

But in my yoga practice, whether I am working on flexibility, strength, orbalance, I find greater value when I hold the postures for longer periods of time, and move very slowly and with a great deal of attention and sensitivity from one posture to the next. This gives me plenty of time to feel into what I am doing.

Slow yoga allows me to discover subtle variations in alignment ­ on both physical and energetic levels. It also allows me to tune in to any emotions that might want to come bubbling up. Most importantly, this mode of yoga allows me to move deeper and deeper without injuring myself, and for the practice to truly be a meditation unto itself.

So, like both eating and making love (or really anything else worth doing), a slower pace allows for a deeper and more intense experience.

I don’t judge people who patronize fast food establishments. But I truly feel sorry for those who don’t allow themselves the fully sensual experience of a meal made up of real food, consumed slowly and attentively.

Given the choice, which of the two alternatives provides more real nourishment?

Namaste, and take it slow.

 

 

Love elephant and want to go steady?

Sign up for our (curated) daily and weekly newsletters!

Editor: Renée Picard

Image: Nikto Shlavic at Flickr 


2,204 views

About Dr. Gregg D. Winston

Dr. Gregg D. Winston, DC, has 35 years experience practicing and teaching Hatha Yoga and Chinese Internal Arts. A 1983 graduate of Dartmouth College, Gregg majored in Comparative Religion with a focus on Eastern Religions and Spirituality. Gregg graduated from the National College of Chiropractic in 1989, and has practiced as a Chiropractic Physician in Boca Raton, and Miramar, FL.

Gregg met his primary teacher, Sifu Glenn Gurman of Norwich Vermont in 1979. With Sifu Gurman, Gregg studied Hatha Yoga, Taijiquan, Baguazhang, and multiple forms of Qigong. Sifu Gurman also introducted Gregg to his first Zen Teacher, Daneel Amos, and to Master Leung Kai Chi of Cambridge, MA. Gregg studied Traditional Yang Style Taijiquan with Sifu Leung, as well as Baguazhang..

Gregg currently lives and works in Ft Lauderdale, FL, where he teaches group classes and sees private students at Heart & Soul Yoga and Wellness Center. Gregg’s teaching philosophy emphasizes providing his students with the motivation, knowledge, and capacity necessary to enable them to practice independently. Gregg may be reached here.

Comments

10 Responses to “Are We Ready for a Slow Yoga Movement? ~ Dr. Gregg D. Winston”

  1. John says:

    I’ve nothing against slow yoga. I practice slowly myself sometimes. I do tire of people who completely fail to understand how genuinely dynamic yoga works (on any level) dismissing what they don’t understand. I can do an iyengar class – no direct focus on breath or bandhas, body never gets warm, stop, start, mess about with props, stop again, start again… Or I can flow smoothly focusing all my attention on breath, Bandha, drishti, and taking each pose to the point where it instantaneously turns into the next “on its own” – evenness of breath, evenness of movement, evenness of mind”-focus total and lucid and alert, everything simultaneously requiring total mental and physical effort and yet somehow effortless, continuos effortless effort. It may not work for you but don’t dismiss what you can’t understand as the yoga equivalent of fast food. Frankly, it’s the same with martial arts, slow practice of internal arts has many benefits, but those who laud it at the expense of rapid practice of applications are all too often woefully inadequate when it comes to demonstrating any ability in the arts primary purpose. Both are necessary and going for a nice run instead isn’t going to make up for cutting one out entirely

  2. Gregg Winston says:

    John,

    Thanks for the thoughtful reply. I would never suggest that yoga only be practiced slowly. What I think I am seeing, at least in my area and on social media is what I would consider an over-extension in the yang direction. In order to come back into dynamic balance, a more yin or internal approach should to be added/increased.

    Namaste,

    Gregg

  3. John says:

    Bear in mind that "balance" is holistic and over any given week most of us spend far less time than we would like moving quickly and far more time than we would like static. It takes a very, very, "yang" practice to balance the "yin" of sitting at a desk 9 hours a day.

  4. nesh says:

    Amen! Great article. I so know what you mean Gregg. I tell my students to feel the pose not do the pose. And that can be achieved after staying in a pose, focusing on the flow of the breath, finding softness and the flow of that qi baby 🙂 Happy practice to all
    nesh

  5. nesh says:

    Amen! Great article. I so know what you mean Gregg. I tell my students to feel the pose not do the pose. And that can be achieved after staying in a pose, focusing on the flow of the breath, finding softness and the flow of that qi baby 🙂 Happy practice to all

  6. akismet-a2e096fffffc5e21b4e477dca5826995 says:

    There is no need to do what any yoga instructor in a studio class says to the letter. They want you to move out of of pose too soon? Ignore them and hold it as long as you need, then rejoin the flow later. Also, if you have a "parayoga" teacher in your area, they are likely to hold the poses longer.

  7. Lars B. says:

    if that's how you feel about vinyasa yoga then don't to a vinyasa yoga class. It's not the teacher's fault you didn't like the class, it's your own fault for not doing some research into what vinyasa is. Had you done just that you'd know what to expect.
    I do a lot of different types of workouts but I would never go to a crossfit class because I've looked into it and therefore know what to expect and so I know it's not for me.
    If you like to stay in each asana for ten breaths or longer then vinyasa is not for you. Don't blame the teacher, don't blame vinyasa.

  8. Jen says:

    It is a misconception of recent years that vinyasa = fast. What was practiced and taught as vinyasa a decade ago is almost unrecognizable today. While it is possible to teach vinyasa in a thoughtful, deliberate and meditative manner, these days people have come to expect a practice where students are flinging themselves around and hoping for the best. Vinyasa means "to place in a certain way" and that is not what is going on in a lot of yoga rooms. No one is given enough time for the "certain way" part and it's showing up as really bad and potentially injurious habits.

  9. Slow yoga? Lol. Yoga is supposed to be slow anyways. But it's been completely usurped by the West into something it's not. It looks more like a gym class than actual Yoga, with all that music, lululemon pants, and white women with Indian names.

  10. klassman says:

    "I don’t judge people who patronize fast food establishments. But I truly feel sorry for those who don’t allow themselves the fully sensual experience …"
    Sounds like a whole lot of judgment.