February 20, 2015

Dear Mr. Nice Guy: Let’s Just Be Friends.

Google images for reuse

How many of us have turned ourselves inside out angsting over breaking up with the nice guy?

If you have, you know it’s brutal.

He’s attractive, kind, nice and giving, but there’s something there we just can’t respond to, something that makes us shut down sexually and send him straight into the friend-zone.

It’s easy enough to break up with the asshole, but the nice guy is an entirely different story.

Is it that we don’t really want the nice guys?

Not at all. It’s because we don’t want what the nice guy has to offer.

While most of us do want a nice, kind and giving man, we only want him to a point.

When a man is too nice, too kind or too giving, we sense bullshit. No one is nice all of the time except for pleasers, over givers and Mr. Nice Guys.

If a man falls into one of these categories, at first he might seem wonderful, but below the surface, on some level, he’s a liar—ultimately because he’s lying to himself.

Let’s start with Mr. Nice Guy. Women don’t want assholes, but we do want real. Mr. Nice Guy is too willing to compromise and never pushes back. He’ll bend over backwards for his woman while stepping on his own self-respect. Respect breeds respect.

When a man has no boundaries and gives seemingly endlessly, there’s no container there. Container as in an edge to experience and actually feel the other. Being with Mr. Nice Guy becomes boring.

Dating Mr. Nice Guy is stagnant. It’s like dating yourself. There’s nothing to push up against, and ultimately we don’t feel met. Being in a relationship with Mr. Nice Guy is like dancing alone with no lead.

Want to go to a movie tonight? Sure.

Oh scratch that, want to go tomorrow? Sure.

Oh my plans fell through tonight, are you available? Sure.

Would it be okay if I cancelled our plans to meet the girls tonight? Sure.

Women don’t want jerks, but we do want some flavor and some backbone. If a man is constantly agreeable, there’s nothing to add flavor to our world and we might as well be solo.

Which leads me to Pleasers. Pleasers don’t express their moods or their opinions because they’re so focused outside themselves, desperately seeking approval.

Pleasers become out of touch with what they really want and need because they’re not tapped into who they really are or what they really feel.

But here’s where the deception ultimately resides: pleasers lie to themselves.

Pleasers tend to be so scared of losing who they want, they set their own needs aside and deny what they feel in order to, well…please.

At first it’s hard to decipher, but when we’re is in a relationship with a pleaser or overly nice guy, eventually the truth behind his actions is revealed—he’s scared and he’s needy.

Needy men give to get back versus giving from a place of truth inside their hearts.

It’s one thing to compromise within a relationship and want to make your partner happy, but it’s quite another to sacrifice your own needs. Needy men have no needs, except for the woman in front of them—you!

What first appears to be adoration and romance, soon becomes suffocating. With needy men, there’s a lack of groundedness that’s palatable because needy men aren’t truly embodied. They live outside themselves and try to enmesh with the other.

Healthy women want to grow. We want to stretch. When we’re with Mr. Nice Guy or Mr. Pleaser, we feel selfish because there’s no healthy way to match their over giving. We eventually feel stagnant because there’s no one to grow along with in life. Suddenly we feel like the man and the woman in the relationships because we’re calling all of the shots all of the time.

When we’re directing every aspect of our movie together, soon the pressure shuts us down.

So what’s the one thing needy men, Mr. Nice Guys and pleasers all have in common?

They are all over givers.

Over givers are ultimately selfish. On the surface they may appear to be easy going and kind, but there’s a dark agenda often hidden from even themselves. There tends to be an empty hole deep inside that was never tended to, healed or self sourced.

While it’s one thing to compromise and prioritize the relationship, it’s quite another to over do all of that.

As much as men don’t want a drama queen or someone who can’t take care of herself, women want a fully embodied man who has done the work on himself and is able to fill those empty holes on the inside, by himself.

When a man learns to express who he really is, while tending to his own needs and having an opinion and life of his own, that’s when we’re attracted to them.

Men (like women) who are wounded early on in life tend to want to please in order to receive love. They don’t know their own self worth and instead identify their worth through the relationship.

Children who were neglected emotionally often grow up learning to manipulate the other for attention and love versus having healthy self-esteem and self love. Over giving, pleasing and playing nice for love are all examples of this manipulation.

Learning to self resource his own needs allows us to partner together as self resourced healthy adults.

Standing there with an empty bucket and hoping to fill it through the relationship with us, does not.

It’s not that we don’t want the nice guys, it’s that we want fully embodied men holding a full bucket.


Relephant Read:

How to exit the Friendzone.



Post adapted generously with permission from Daily Transformations 

Author: Tamara Star

Editor: Emily Bartran

Photo: Google Images for Reuse

You must be logged in to post a comment. Create an account.

Bill Winfield Apr 27, 2019 2:52pm

Nice Job! It took me 30+ years to figure this out. Hopefully some get it, but ignore the negative feedback you are right on with the shared wisdom.

James Jan 18, 2016 5:10am

I think all this "nice guys stuff" is share immaturity. If someone is really committed to a long and respected relationship, not that infatuation feelings that end relationships in months, there is nothing like he or she is too nice. My question is would you like the bad guy to father your children?

Greg Dec 25, 2015 12:39am

A lot of women pay lip service to the idea that they want men who are submissive or obedient to them, or that 'good' guys deserve to end up with someone better than them. Women are more attracted to arrogant, selfish men who place very little value on them relative to other women and see them as disposable and replaceable. Women like men who will do whatever it takes to get what they want and don't care who gets hurt in the process. For a woman to admit that would destroy her reputation, however. Men are attracted to fit, good-looking women, regardless of what they're like. Everyone knows that. It's about power. Women want to control and exploit men, and men want to control and exploit women. That's what 'love' is.

Read Elephant’s Best Articles of the Week here.
Readers voted with your hearts, comments, views, and shares:
Click here to see which Writers & Issues Won.

Tamara Star

Tamara Star believes happiness is not an end destination, but instead the ability to see the ordinary through eyes of wonder.

Want her free tips and tricks for health, happiness and love?
Click here.

Receive her free 3 video series for clearing the slate for more love & happiness.
Click here.

She’s an international best-selling author and the creator of the original 40-day Personal reboot program for women–a 6 week virtual deep dive into clearing the slate on what’s blocking you. Registration is open NOW here.

Tamara’s global reach inspires women around the world through her programs, newsletters, and teachings.

She’s been featured on SiriusXM radio, Good Morning America, former Oprah producer LeGrande Green’s GetBOLD radio, Dr. Brenda Wade’s GoodLove Radio, Daybreak USA and News Australia.

Connect with Tamara on her websiteFacebook or Twitter.

Tamara’s work had been translated into 6 languages and featured on The Huffington Post, MindBodyGreen, Positively Positive, Yahoo News, The News.com Australia, The Good Men Project, and Yoga Anonymous.