All Love is Created Equal

Via on May 22, 2008

Last issue featured a social-political cover depicting the importance of recognizing gay marriage as equal under the law, whatever your opinion of gays. Our editor-in-chief’s letter attempted to draw the difference between liking something personally and supporting something politically.

I should know better than to believe that an editorial written by a straight would come anywhere near to grasping what it is like to be queer. With your opening paragraph, you joined the legions of people who reduce being gay to a sexual act. Being a queer male is about so much more than where my dick ends up. But thanks for the reminder to approach cautiously when reading supposedly “enlightened” editorial. To assist you in your understanding, being gay is more about finding a caring, committed, supportive, loving relationship with another person who is of the same sex. It’s also about looking at the world through a completely different lens. I stopped reading the issue after 62 words. Side note: a wedding ring is worn on your left hand, not the right hand as shown on your cover. Cheers, Eric L. Ross, Dartmouth, Nova Scotia

>

I went on to say that gays, like all people, deserve equal rights. It’s just my jarring style of writing. Please read the rest if you can bear it, it gets easier, and let me know if I missed the point. I’ll be happy to correct anything or publish… …anything to undo any harm I’ve done. ~ed.

I actually really liked Waylon’s intro. I thought it was clever to boil it down to a simple matter of personal preference on where wee-wees can go, which is a) pretty funny and b) pretty accurate. It was more his middle, where he went through a gauntlet of biblical, historical and zoological justifications for homosexuality. I guess I find these arguments to be tiresome because they are all inconsistent for many of the same reasons anti-gay rights arguments are inconsistent. Perhaps I’m being idealistic, but I feel these arguments are premised on responding to anti-gay rights arguments, not on their capacity to make their own argument for gay rights. When he gets back down to going on the offensive, that little “click your heels” section, his point is strongest. Because it really is that simple. Overall, I read this as an editorial written by someone who knows he doesn’t need to think about this, and knows it doesn’t affect him specifically, but has figured out a simple way of thinking about it that shows just how wrong it is to be against gay rights, which is probably what most straight people need to hear. This editorial isn’t meant for us, it’s directed specifically at those who blissfully ignore the issue. Also, go Brad Pitt. Arguably my favorite quote on that page. It’s the most individualized form of activism possible. I look forward to future issues, in both senses of the word. Best, Joshua Ehrenreich > Amen, Josh.

>

I wasn’t writing for folks who already agree with me. That’s the rhetorical equivalent of patting oneself on the back, oh, how enlightened we are! I was writing it for idiots like myself who are homophobic physically but unlike myself conflate that visceral, personal homophobia with social and political spheres. If I don’t fancy the taste of tomatoes I don’t have to eat them, let alone make them illegal for others. ~ed.

Desktop/Tablet banner

About elephantjournal dotcom

474 views

Appreciate this article? Support indie media!

(We use super-secure PayPal - but don't worry - you don't need an account with PayPal.)

Elephriends - Mindful Partners

190x1902-EJ-clothing

3 Responses to “All Love is Created Equal”

  1. [...] of view (one can always hope). So now it’s your turn: this issue, our readers wrote in on  same-sex marriage, the death of “real yoga” and the repeated interjection of “[laughter]” in interviews. [...]

Leave a Reply