Why The Olympics Would Ruin Yoga. ~ Kerry Maiorca

Via on Aug 23, 2012

Every few years, when the Olympics roll around, there is a renewed push from an insistent camp of yogis trying to get yoga in the Olympics.

I am not usually one to take a hard stand about yoga; when students ask me what I think about Bikram or Hot yoga—or any of the latest trends in the industry—my genuine response is that although it’s not for me, it works well for some students.

The diversity available in yoga today is part of the beauty of the practice and there is a particular style or approach that suits each individual.

To that end, although I, personally, am not a supporter of yoga competitions, I can respect the fact that they serve a purpose for some yoga practitioners.

Just not in the Olympics.

Yoga competitions are like any other PR-grabbing commodity in the yoga industry—they exist to make headlines and money—and fortunately, the general public is largely unaware of their existence.

If yoga took to the Olympic stage, competitive yoga would become the representative of all yoga—and yoga would be perceived as one more unattainable, misunderstood endeavor, to the average-Joe couch potato.

Yoga has come a long way since I started practicing over 15 years ago; it used to be that when I mentioned that I was a yoga teacher, the first question in response was “Can you wrap your legs behind your head?”

Olympic yoga would set us back years in that regard because of the way it would reinforce the wow factor and the misperception the crazier the pose, the more advanced the yogi. Yoga is one of the few remaining safe places where competition is set aside, at least in theory. On the mat, it’s not about being more or being better…but rather about just being.

Imagine if your asana practice was fueled by a desire to achieve perfection.

Ahimsa, non-harming, is the first tenet of yoga.

This would be a problem for an elite yoga athlete who, in order to become an Olympian, would have to train harder than everyone else, pushing past the body’s signs of injury, to stay step above the competition.

And, what about the concepts of asteya, non-coveting and of santosha, contentment?

Why can’t the Jordyn Wiebers of the world just be content with all they have achieved, instead of grasping for that elusive, all-around gold medal?

The saying goes that all PR is good PR—but in the case of yoga, it isn’t necessarily so. Imagine the confusion a new student would feel coming into a class after having seen yogis compete in the Olympics. It would appear contradictory if the teacher suggested students avoid pushing too hard or comparing themselves to others—and any insistence that the shape of the poses is not what matters would seem silly and disingenuous, if that was the standard by which an Olympic yogi was judged.

Now is the time yoga must become even less competitive and less image-focused, in order to counter our strongly competitive, image-based society.

Yoga is not about achievement; it’s about the process of continually coming into the moment.

Unfortunately, that doesn’t make for very good television ratings.

As a former competitive gymnast, volleyball and softball player myself, I’m wowed by what the Olympic athletes can accomplish physically.

But even more impressive is their mental discipline—and the hours of training and dedication that lead them to that one crucial, stress-inducing peak moment that distinguishes Gold, Silver and Bronze, from the others.

By contrast, the practice of yoga teaches us that every moment is a peak moment because the present is all that we have, this moment is all that’s real. And therefore, instead of experiencing the extreme joy of winning the gold or the devastation of losing out on a medal, yogis pursue the steady path to sustained contentment, despite wins and losses, ups and downs.

My biggest objection to the idea of yoga as an Olympic event is that as in gymnastics, in which a routine is assigned a maximum, perfect start value and deductions are taken for any perceived errors, a scored asana competition makes perfection the goal.

I’ve tried the whole yoga-as-a-quest-for-perfection thing—and I can’t say I recommend it.

When I first started yoga, I was so taken with the practice that I made it my life’s mission to follow the perfect diet, speak the perfect words and perform the perfect asana practice.

As a result I became rigid, self-obsessed, even joyless and I began to see yoga as just one more way that I couldn’t measure up to those around me.

Eventually, after hearing teachers encourage me over and over again to just be where I was that day, embrace my imperfections and have compassion for myself when I slipped up, I learned to look beyond perfection to something more truthful and joyful: the imperfect reality.

I can only hope that yoga’s retreat from perfection keeps the practice far away from the Olympic stage, so that all practitioners, of varying levels of fitness and experience, may experience peak moments day in and day out, rather than limiting the glory to an elite few, every four years.

 

Kerry Maiorca got into yoga for all the wrong reasons but continues practicing for the right ones. As the Director of Bloom Yoga Studio in Chicago, Kerry joyfully pursues imperfection on a daily basis and invites others to join her in this worthy pursuit at  Thinking Yogi and Bloom Yoga Studio.

 

 

~

Editor: Bryonie Wise

Like elephant yoga on Facebook.

About elephant journal

elephant journal is dedicated to "bringing together those working (and playing) to create enlightened society." We're about anything that helps us to live a good life that's also good for others, and our planet. >>> Founded as a print magazine in 2002, we went national in 2005 and then (because mainstream magazine distribution is wildly inefficient from an eco-responsible point of view) transitioned online in 2009. >>> elephant's been named to 30 top new media lists, and was voted #1 in the US on twitter's Shorty Awards for #green content...two years running. >>> Get involved: > Subscribe to our free Best of the Week e-newsletter. > Follow us on Twitter Fan us on Facebook. > Write: send article or query. > Advertise. > Pay for what you read, help indie journalism survive and thrive. Questions? info elephantjournal com

3,128 views

Appreciate this article? Support indie media!

(We use super-secure PayPal - but don't worry - you don't need an account with PayPal.)

14 Responses to “Why The Olympics Would Ruin Yoga. ~ Kerry Maiorca”

  1. yoga chick says:

    Amen sister. I totally agree with everything you say

  2. Karen says:

    I couldn't agree more!

  3. Gwen says:

    As I attend classes at the Bloom Yoga Studio fairly regularly my comments may be somewhat less than objective – but I can't imagine that the addition of competition to my practice would help me in any way except to highlight my shortcomings. I will never be able to stand on my head or wrap my legs around my head, but each class gives me the opportunity to be in the moment just for myself – maybe able to do something I couldn't do last week, maybe not. I always leave class feeling positive and just happy – and part of that is the obvious joy all my teachers have for their practice.

    • Such a beautiful thing, Gwen, to leave yoga class feeling positive and happy rather than obsessing about wrapping your legs behind your head. I'm with you – yoga should be just about 'the opportunity to be in the moment just for yourself.' Thanks for reading!

  4. Edward Staskus says:

    You make several good points, especially about the problem of competitive yoga being brought into the studio, where it would be inappropriate, given that asana isn't yoga, only a part of it, not the whole. Anyway, I am not sure if the Olympics is really interested in yoga as it is presently configured. Maybe if some enterprising American yogi could fashion a new practice, something like combat yoga, maybe performed in a boxing-like ring, that might be a proposal the IOC would consider.

    • Edward, you're probably right that the IOC wouldn't consider yoga in the way it's currently practiced, but it's all the more frightening to imagine about what an Olympic Yoga proposal would look like and how it would impact the larger yoga community. It's the 'enterprising yogis' that I'm worried about, and I hope any yoga practitioners who are tempted to go for the glory keep their Olympic aspirations to themselves so we don't have Team USA trying to defeat Team Russia in combat yoga or rhythmic yoga or any other variation of competitive, scored asana practice. Yikes.

  5. Hanna says:

    What an insightful article! I only want to learn yoga from someone with your philosophy! I so appreciate all you teach me, whether is has to do with yoga or not!

  6. [...] a javelin or being able to run extremely fast for 26.2 miles is an impressive attribute—but it’s hardly going to save the world. Some people benefit from the happy accidents of having [...]

  7. Thanks for the kind comment, Hanna. So glad you enjoyed the article!

  8. Kerry says:

    Love this article Kerry! I definitely agree that I come to my yoga mat to get out of my head and be able to accept and enjoy the present moment. Somedays are harder than others. I really liked how you brought up ahisma, asteya, and santosha. I struggle with all of these but enjoy teaching them to my students. Students already have a hard time not comparing themselves to other students and magazine covers. Making yoga an Olympic sport with make this even more challenging. Thank you for you wise words and sharing your story!

  9. So glad you enjoyed the article, Kerry. It's funny how as yoga teachers we are encouraging students to do something that we haven't really 'mastered' either. The art of being present and getting out of the normal mode of thinking and being is such a never-ending project. Just imagine – if people thought yoga was just about achieving 'perfect' form, the conversation about the mind would never even happen. Olympic Yogis would be too busy judging themselves and their poses to bother with that pesky mindfulness stuff. Thanks for reading and commenting!

  10. [...] Yoga in the West is basically about posture, otherwise known as asana. As such, yoga has had a huge success all over the world and the physical benefits are often remarkable. Some think it is so good, physically challenging and spectacular that it ought to be part of the Olympic games. [...]

Leave a Reply