Obey: Re-evaluating the Fluoridation of Tap Water.

Via Brigitte Mars
on Apr 7, 2009
get elephant's newsletter

water faucet, kitchen sink, fluoride, fluoridation

If you saw what the river carried, you would never drink the water.

~ Jamaican Proverb

In order for something to become clean, something else must become dirty.

~ Imbesi’s Conservation of Filth Law

Next to air, water is the most essential nutrient for life. Chemicals are added to your drinking water to make it safe to drink—and fluoride’s one of them. But fluoride isn’t a nutrient—it’s a nonessential trace mineral, the 13th most common element in the earth’s crust. Unlike minerals like calcium and magnesium, fluoride has never been found essential for human life. And even the Environmental Protection Agency has called for more studies to determine the risks of fluoridating water.

The word fluoride is derived from the Latin root fluor, meaning, “to flow.”Elemental fluoride is called fluorine, an especially tiny atom that appears as a pale yellow gas. Sodium fluoride is a by-product of the aluminum industry, as well as the phosphate, pesticide, gasoline, coal burning, fertilizer, uranium, glass, steel, beryllium and copper industries. It has the unique property of reducing the temperature at which molten metals flows out of ore. Teflon plastic, waterproof clothing, and even drugs such as Prozac and Cipro use fluoride. Of the 27 major tranquilizers, seven are fluoride compounds.

Fluoride is an industrial pollutant, more toxic than lead, non-biodegradable and expensive to dispose of. It’s the second largest pollutant in Canada and, during the Cold War, was blamed for more environmental damage than 20 other major air pollutants combined. Much of the fluoride added to today’s drinking water is “scrubbed” from the Florida phosphate fertilizer factories smokestacks to help prevent damage to surrounding crops and livestock. Fluorocarbon, another common pollutant, is made by fluoride tightly bonding to carbon atoms. Even one part hydrogen fluoride in the air can etch glass!

During World War II, the German I.G. Farben Companyplanned to fluoridate the water of occupied countries, believing that it caused slight brain damage to specific areas of the brain, making a person docile toward authority. The idea of putting fluoride in American water supplies came from the Mellon Institute, the main research facility for ALCOA (Aluminum Company of America)—one of the largest fluoride polluters on Earth. How convenient to have a method of disposing of an otherwise useless industrial pollutant at we taxpayers’ expense! By the mid-1930’s fluoride was linked by European scientists to respiratory disorders, central nervous system problems and musculoskeletal ailments. Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Egypt, France, Germany, Holland, India, Italy, Japan, Luxembourg, Norway, Spain and Sweden have said ‘No, thanks’to water fluoridation. Fluorine tends to be utilized by the body in place of iodine, thus contributing to thyroid enlargement and sometimes hypothyroid function. Is it any wonder Synthroid, a medicine for low thyroid function, is a top-selling drug, of which osteoporosisis a side effect? Fluoride-using lab animals exhibit kidney damage, including chronic nephritis, bone and tooth damage. It’s a known carcinogen and has been linked to elevated cancer risks in rats, mice and human.

According to a 1943 issue of JAMA (Journal of the American Medical Association), “Fluorides are generally protoplasmic poisons, probably because of their capacity to modify metabolism of the cells by changing the permeability of the cell membrane, and by inhibiting certain enzyme systems. Fluoride has been linked in many studies to brain impairment, low sperm and testosterone count, infertility, kidney stones, depression, atherosclerosis, oral cancers and cataracts.

Fluorides rapidly bind to calcium, causing the cell membranes to harden and inhibit collagen production. They break down the sulfhydral links composing the protein-based connective tissues. Fluoride combines with stomach acids to form hydrofluoric acid, which can dissolve protein (and steel and glass!). Like lead, fluoride also accumulates in your bones. In plants, fluoride exposure can interfere with photosynthesis.

Fluoride does not prevent tooth decay when ingested. It is only considered effective when applied topically, not swallowed. Excess fluoride can cause mottling (spotting that includes white blotches) ofthe teeth. Fluoride tablets have been known to cause digestive disturbances, skin rash, headache, weakened immunity and weakness— all of which disappear when fluoride is discontinued. The Food and Drug Administration does not approve of fluoride in the form of drops or tablets. Each tube of fluoride toothpaste contains between 1,000 to 2,000 milligrams of fluoride, which is enough to kill a small child who might decide to eat the entire thing. And while it’s impossible to determine how much water a person consumes, athletes, those in hot climates, diabetics and those with kidney ailments might consume much more water than average.

article, faucet, elephant

In 1945, Public Health Servicescheduled a 10-year double blind study in which the waters of Newburg, New York would be fluoridated, while the water of nearby Kingston, New York would not be. After only five years, the study was abruptly halted after it found that the children in fluoridated Newburg had 50% more dental decay than in Kingston. Still, the American Dental Association promoted fluoridation. It is also curious that the studies used were done with calcium fluoride, yet what actually goes into water supplies is sodium fluoride.

In 1945, water fluoridation began in Grand Rapids, Michigan. A lawyer from ALCOA who was appointed to a position at Public Health Service launched the campaign to portray fluoride as a protector of children.

It is said that fluoride makes dental enamel more resistant to the acids in foods. Wouldn’t it be safer to limit sugar intake, and floss and brush our teeth? After all, many things once considered safe and beneficial have since been shown to be bad for us: mercury dental fillings, herbicides, DDT, lead in gasoline and paint, aluminum in deodorants, methyl and propyl parabens, asbestos and synthetic hormones in food. Perhaps fluoridation needs to be re-evaluated?


Update: “Harvard Study Finds Fluoride Lowers IQ. Further, the EPA says fluoride is a chemical “with substantial evidence of developmental neurotoxicity.” (reuters.com)


About Brigitte Mars

Brigitte Mars is an herbalist and nutritional consultant of Natural Health with over forty years of experience. She teaches Herbal Medicine at Naropa University, Bauman College of Holistic Nutrition, The School of Natural Medicine, Living Arts School and Heilseimestraskollin in Iceland. She has taught at Omega Institute, Esalen, Kripalu and The Mayo Clinic, She blogs for the Huffington Post and Care2. She is a professional member of the American Herbalist Guild. Brigitte is the author of many books and DVDs, including The Home Reference to Holistic Health and Healing, The Country Almanac of Home Remedies, The Desktop Guide to Herbal Medicine, Beauty by Nature, Addiction Free Naturally, The Sexual Herbal, Healing Herbal TeasRawsome! and co-author of The HempNut Cookbook. DVDs include Sacred Psychoactives, Herbal Wizardry for Kids of all Ages, Natural Remedies for Childhood Ailments and Natural Remedies for Emotional Health. Her latest project is a phone app called IPlant. Brigitte and her daughter, Sunflower Sparkle Mars run Herb Camp for Kids in Boulder, Colorado. Brigitte's other daughter is world famous activist/yogini-actress/supermodel, Rainbeau Mars. Please check out her website.


6 Responses to “Obey: Re-evaluating the Fluoridation of Tap Water.”

  1. a well-informed friend of mine just emailed me, said, the above isn't too well-researched. I welcome another, perhaps more in depth look at whether fluoride is in fact bad for health, or not.

  2. John says:

    Actually, it is quite well researched and concise.

    For links to studies and a more in-depth look like you wanted, try this link:

    Seldom is it mentioned that the first use of fluoridated water was in Nazi concentration camps. Were they concerned about tooth decay?

    Why did Margaret Thatcher order Irish water supplies fluoridated when there was all the IRA trouble?

  3. Tee says:

    This has been a concern of mine for some time, and is one reason I like living here; the water is neither fluoridated nor chlorinated. It definitely makes an impact on the ability to think more clearly, without signs of a mellow, placated populations. It also makes washing dishes more frequently a must, as the absence of chlorine results in a more scummy residue if water is left to soak in dirty dishes. Still, I'm happier to be a free-thinking dishwasher than a sheep wearing blinders.

  4. BG Jack D. Ripper says:

    Which is why I drink only rainwater and grain alcohol. As anyone knows, fluoridation is a vicious and subversive communist plot to sap and impurify our precious bodily fluids.

  5. […] water is dirty and full of flouride and sits around in pipes. Bottled water comes from a spring and is tested for […]

  6. johnnny5 says:

    Men of science have spoken passionately against fluoride and fluoridation. Phillipe Grandjean has remarked on the lack of good studies on fluoride’s affect on the brain. (though we’ve been putting it in the water for 60 years) Dean Burk called it public murder on a grand scale after heading a department at the American Cancer society and studying and working there for 34 years on groundbreaking lifesaving research. Aarvid Caarlson winner of the 2000 Nobel Prize in medicine advised the government of Sweden and recommends pharmacologically active substances not be added to the environment. nor medication given to the public instead of the individual. He called it obsolete. "I am opposed to fluoridation because of the overwhelming evidence that fluoridation is not only potentially harmful but has already caused considerable, well-documented harm." Albert Schatz, Ph.D., biochemistry, world-renowned discoverer of streptomycin (Oct., 1999)Toxic waste should not be diluted then dumped into the ground and the waterways (through mopping sprinklers, toilets, baths, and washing) and it certainly shouldn’t be used to grow food, prepare food, be in most beverages and in one of life’s necessities. Most of the world has stopped doing this. More people receive artificially fluoridated water in the United States than the rest of the world combined. It may be good for teeth at 1-3mg per day, but the dosage you get is probably higher. It affects the thyroid, the pineal, the brain, the kidneys, and the bones. There are no studies of fluoride in regards to dermal absorption though when looking at similar issues intake when showering or bathing is often even higher than when drinking. If we drink, eat, brush with, and bathe in fluoride what is our total intake? There are few or no studies on many of these issues, and that is why you are told so frequently that fluoridation is safe. Why are there no studies of this nature after 68 years of fluoridation? This is about more than just teeth. Men of science speak against this, but to find anything for it one must turn to agencies, organizations, and bureaucracies.

    There is fluoride in most food:
    from the USDA http://www.ars.usda.gov/SP2UserFiles/Place/123545

    While daily intake of 1–3 mg of fluoride prevents dental caries, long-term exposure to higher amounts may have deleterious effects on tooth enamel and bone. from the world health organization. http://www.euro.who.int/__data/assets/pdf_file/00

    “according to clinical research, the fluoride dose capable of reducing thyroid function was notably low-just 2-5 mg per day over several months” (Galetti & Joyce 1958) “this dose is well within the range (1.6 to 6.6 mg/day) of what individuals living in fluoridated communities are now estimated to receive on a daily basis.”

    Fluoride is a neurotoxin http://www.epa.gov/ncct/toxcast/files/summit/48P%

    But don’t take my word for it. Read it yourself. It’s out there. If you are only skeptical about that which you are uncertain you are not using skepticism properly. Take out your beliefs and give them an airing out on occasion.