Are Whole Foods and Walmart shoppers the same? ~ Frances Killea

Via elephant journal
on May 4, 2012
get elephant's newsletter
Photo by David Blackwell

The Fast Pace of Slow Food.

An observation on the behavior of “conscious” consumers.

Are Whole Foods and Walmart shoppers the same?

John nearly fell backwards on his heels as the woman swooped in, nosing him out of the way as she clawed the last four jars of fig jam from the shelf. Her maneuver was quick and clean; as we blinked after her, she marched towards the checkout with a self-satisfied click in her step. I bit my tongue and glanced at my friend, still crouched over, a jar of strawberry jelly in each hand.

We had undertaken a quest to round out our pantries, driving to the nearest Trader Joe’s market in search of bananas and bread. We had no further plans but to make sandwiches in the back of the car before heading home. I suppose we are drawn to Trader Joe’s for the same reasons every other patron is: affordable packaged foods and pantry staples, a variety of hard-to-find items, and a relatively quirky and fun experience. John and I were surprised by the jelly aisle incident; it seemed absurd that in a Hawaiian-themed grocery someone should be so brusque.

Photo: scaredy_kat

As attention to healthy living grows, so too do the energy and culture around the concept. Where once the local food co-op was a lonely entity in a sea of colorful supermarkets, cars now flood the parking lots of natural foods stores, and foot traffic around bulk sections causes jams in the aisles. The busy-ness indicates something, but is it solely driven by a desire for better wellbeing?

The image of the organic Eden, pushed by alt-food-manufacturers, is a silent irony when stamped onto packages destined for busy groceries. The closest most shoppers come to pastoral tranquility in a long checkout line might be the illustration on a box of cereal. The so-called “foodie” phenomenon (a blanket term referring to the noise about farmer’s markets, urban gardening, up-and-coming chefs, and the push for eating un- or less processed foods) vilifies factory farming and assembly-line eateries, pushing instead the notion of slow food. It seems, however, that against an insidious, invisible anxiety, the spirit of the slow food movement is at risk.

Photo by Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources

I work with a farmer during the growing season, helping set up, sell produce, and break down the stand at two busy markets in downtown Cleveland. After the appearance of raspberries, our tent starts to garner a crowd, and with the advent of the summer’s first peaches, we draw a line sometimes twenty people deep.

The affectation of the early birds, perching determinedly in front of the table long before we open at 8am, is tense. People tersely engage in polite small talk; friendly exchanges seem only to materialize when both parties have their choice produce in hand, guaranteed. Further down, customers peer over the line to see how many pints of berries are left, and if they aren’t actually tapping their feet, their faces betray their frustration. While no one’s ever thrown a punch, people have gotten into nasty verbal tiffs, talking about line-cutting rules like fifth graders. Behind the stand, my partner and I have been criticized for not working hard enough or fast enough, and have even weathered the critical growls of a man frustrated by his wait in the rain.

Asked about their motivation for buying produce directly from the source or dining at restaurants known for sourcing local ingredients, any of these people will happily explain that they value hard work and local commerce. Their desire to discover a calm, wholesome way of living starts with food, followed by the mindfulness and appreciation that ought to accompany every meal. In theory, shoppers’ reasons are as pure as the supper they might prepare with their market spoils, but in practice, they often act on the same competitive drive that their ideals should like to renounce.

Decidedly American or not, I don’t know, but this consuming, pervasive sense of rivalry beats under the surface of many, if not most, pursuits. It is obvious in sports and business, and even thickly mortared into high school and college environments. An inescapable need to “perform and succeed” has changed the way we think and feel about education, entrepreneurship, and relationships. Even the trends that went from the mainstream in the name of neutralizing such desperately earnest anxieties have a traceable thread of ferocity.

During the holiday season, reporters share stories of violent mobs wrestling over deals at superstores and shopping malls; no doubt, a self-proclaimed slow-food enthusiast smirks with some pity at these clips. Still, how different are the people arguing in a Whole Foods from those wrestling over a product at Walmart? They are still fighting over a commodity in limited supply: free-range, organic or not.

Frances Killea is a perpetual motion machine. She currently writes from Cleveland, Ohio. You can reach her at [email protected].






Editor: Seychelles Pitton


About elephant journal

elephant journal is dedicated to "bringing together those working (and playing) to create enlightened society." We're about anything that helps us to live a good life that's also good for others, and our planet. >>> Founded as a print magazine in 2002, we went national in 2005 and then (because mainstream magazine distribution is wildly inefficient from an eco-responsible point of view) transitioned online in 2009. >>> elephant's been named to 30 top new media lists, and was voted #1 in the US on twitter's Shorty Awards for #green content...two years running. >>> Get involved: > Subscribe to our free Best of the Week e-newsletter. > Follow us on Twitter. Fan us on Facebook. > Write: send article or query. > Advertise. > Pay for what you read, help indie journalism survive and thrive—and get your name/business/fave non-profit on every page of Questions? Send to [email protected]


9 Responses to “Are Whole Foods and Walmart shoppers the same? ~ Frances Killea”

  1. oz_ says:

    Brilliant!! Incisive! So true!

    The products on offer are not the problem – the mindset we bring to them is the problem. IMO, what you are describing is, plain and simple – immaturity. We are a nation full of nasty, spoiled child-adults, who have never learned to share graciously.

    Of course, this is not surprising – from social role models to political leaders can be described the same way! Sad…

    Thanks for the wake-up call…

  2. Vision_Quest2 says:

    I think this is my second boycott of Whole Foods in the past two years. How they treat their suppliers is key. If it looks like a Wal-Mart duck it probably quacks like a Wal-Mart duck, too. Broke the boycott just to save a few pennies; was supported in my blogsite for getting back with the boycott program.

    How they treat their employees (BMI maximum – no minimum – requirements to get better healthcare benefits) brought on the first one …

    I bring shopping local to a new art … there are so many stores in MY neighborhood that blow Whole Foods out of the water, some with organic produce; nearly all with natural foods departments.

  3. Vision_Quest2 says:

    This link came from another source, however:

    Don't be a small supplier in a sea full of BIG shark distributors (like Whole Foods), no matter what kind of organic food they feed on …

  4. faye says:

    i would argue that these nasty, spoiled child-adults, who have never learned to share graciously as you say are enabled by the customer is king philosophy that pervades the Am. culture. As Frances pointed out her unfortunate encounter with the pressed-for-time crowd or the (clearly) improperly dressed man, I cannot help but wonder what her or her partner's reaction was. did they appease these complainers or compassionately put them in their place with a firm, simple remark? i will never forget a customer in a stationary shop in venice beach, CA who was so unhappy about something as she claimed self-righteously how she should be compensated for the lack of service. the young woman at the counter was holding her own politely but man, when the woman left, i saw how frazzled she was so i spoke with her in an attempt to help her feel calm. giving her the floor to express whatever she needed, she shared her frustration in dealing with über-demanding customers, sharing story after story. it made me think: i had been living in Germany at that point for 3 yrs where customer service was just catching on (at least according to this American), where the business is as it is and the customer MUST adapt, and often heard store clerks or even managers express to complaining customer (if any – they just don't complain compared to our society) so incredibly matter-of-fact the reason for the problem in the first place. and the customer had no choice to accept it.
    the problem i see is that we live in a money driven-state where we bow to the gods of capitalism, sacrificing more than we should just to hold onto customers or to protect a reputation, whereas in Germany it is similar but more different.
    we should all just smile, come clean, and relax, focusing on disabling the enabling. (ok, i'll stop now. )

  5. […] green movement is often seen as a white, Whole Foods loving, Prius-driving, upper middle class, left wing […]

  6. […] many people try to do a “good job” by shopping and eating at the local “heath” food stores: Whole Foods, PCC Natural Markets, Trader Joes, and even the organic section at King Soopers, QFC […]

  7. Md. Razaul Karim says:

    Its amazing! Very helpful information for everyone like me.