Death, Indifference & the Yoga of Caring. ~ Eric Walrabenstein

Via elephant journal
on Nov 3, 2012
get elephant's newsletter

Kitty Genovese is dead.

Stalked, raped, stabbed and left to suffocate in a pool of her own blood in the wee hours of a cold New York night.

Arriving home after her shift as manager at Ev’s Eleventh Hour Sports Bar, Kitty stepped out of her fire-engine red Fiat and began a short, 100-foot walk from her car to the front door of her apartment. She would never make it.

Records show it was about 3:15 a.m. on that night nearly fifty years ago, when Kitty crossed the parking lot and caught the shadow of a man out of the corner of her eye. Frightened, she began to run. But Winston Moseley, a 29-year-old machine operator who had silently slipped out of bed with his wife an hour earlier, was faster.

Moseley quickly overtook Kitty and, as she ran, he plunged a knife into her back. Twice.

“Oh my God, he stabbed me! Help me!” was her first of many cries for help that morning.

Her shrieks of terror were heard by over a dozen neighbors: people jumped from their beds, apartment lights flicked on, neighbors strained their eyes through cold window panes for the source of the screams. Help would surely soon be on its way.

But strangely, it was not, for most of those looking on couldn’t be bothered to help. Only one was spurred to action, and that was Robert Mozer, who raised his window shouting, “Leave that girl alone!” before going back to bed.

Startled by the shout, the attacker Moseley fled the scene, and Kitty was left to stumble around to the back of her building—only to find the door locked. It was there that she crumbled to the ground, wounded, but not mortally so.

Of all the people who had heard the screams and witnessed the first attack, no one came to Kitty’s aid. In fact, no one even called the police. Each of them calmly went back to their books, television programs or comfortable beds, believing at best, that someone else would help, at worst, that it wasn’t their problem.

Thirty minutes later, Moseley returned to finish the job.

Defensive wounds on Kitty’s hands indicated that she fought bravely for her life as she was again stabbed, then raped and left for dead. Kitty Genovese was 28 years old.

On that night, a horrific crime was committed, one for which Winston Moseley remains incarcerated to this day. But Moseley’s crimes weren’t the only one’s committed on that cold March morning—in fact one might argue they weren’t even the worst.

While it’s true that Winston Moseley chased Kitty, and yes, Winston Moseley stabbed Kitty, and yes, Winston Moseley raped Kitty, it wasn’t Winston Moseley who killed Kitty.

It was us.

Several times Kitty screamed for help; several times lights in adjacent apartments came on; several times neighbors peered through their windows at the scene, and yet, nobody acted. According to the New York Times article on the tragedy, the first call into the police wasn’t until 3:50 a.m.—over half an hour after the attack began.

If just one of the witnesses would have acted with courage and determination, Kitty Genovese would very likely be with us today.

So what happened? Why did so many choose to do nothing and allow this poor girl to die a lonely death on a cold New York sidewalk? Was it cold-heartedness? Was it fear? Was it a once in a lifetime fluke?

Sadly no, on every count.

The culprit is something called the Bystander Effect, the Genovese Syndrome or, more technically, Diffusion of Responsibility. It describes a phenomenon where individuals fail to come to the aid of a person in jeopardy when they are in the presence of other witnesses. And the more witnesses, the less likely people are to come to the victim’s aid.

There are all sorts of theories as to why this is so:

Some people fail to act because nobody is watching, making the personal consequence of doing nothing appear less than the act of doing something.

Some people fail to act because nobody else is acting and thus think to themselves, “Why should I?”

Some people fail to act because they believe that with so many others witnessing the same thing, surely someone else will come to the victim’s aid.

But no matter the reasoning, the phenomenon is as unnecessary as it is abhorrent.

Kitty Genovese was murdered, not by Winston Moseley, but by a crowd of apathetic bystanders who chose to ignore her cries for help.

But why are we talking of this tragedy nearly half a century after it occurred?

Simple. Because it’s happening again. Right here, right now—and you are a part of it.

For years, I’ve been working around the clock to get help to our troops and veterans who are fighting a desperate battle against post-traumatic stress. Although it’s not commonly known, hundreds of thousands have returned from their service with lives devastated by the mental and emotional toll of war.

The truth is that an epidemic of psychological wounds has ravaged our military and veteran populations with mind-numbing consequences: legions of families have disintegrated, untold careers have been ruined and thousands upon thousands of mothers have lost their sons and daughters to suicide.

Yet despite this clear and present cry for help; despite hundreds of thousands of pleas through emails, phone calls, Facebook, Twitter, blog posts and media interviews, and most of all, despite a quick and easy means for each of us to gift life-changing help to our warriors in need, but a sliver of those who have been invited to help have lifted so much as a finger.

To the small minority who have acted: I am inspired, I am grateful and I say thank you on behalf of all of our warriors for whom you have made hope and happiness again a possibility. I am proud to stand with you in the name of healing and wholeness in the world. But I also say that collectively, we can do better. A small minority is simply not good enough.

Forty-nine years ago, Kitty Genovese was killed as a handful of apathetic neighbors stood by and did nothing to help—even though saving her life involved but a simple matter of picking up the phone.

“It’s not my problem . . .” or “somebody else will help . . .” or “I don’t want to get involved . . .” they thought.

Today, nineteen of America’s troops and veterans take their own lives each and every day as millions of Americans stand by and do nothing to help—even though saving their lives involves but a simple matter of making a small contribution and encouraging friends to do the same.

“It’s not my problem . . .” or “somebody else will help . . .” or “I don’t want to get involved . . .” we think.

But here’s the thing: it is our problem, it doesn’t matter what anyone else is doing and we must get involved.

We must save Kitty Genovese.

You see, saving Kitty Genovese isn’t about Kitty Genovese—it’s about all of us.

Kitty Genovese is Marine Private Jonathan Schulze who hung himself after reporting to the Veterans Administration he was feeling suicidal and was told to call back.

Kitty Genovese is Army Specialist Jesse Charles Huff who shot himself in the head after leaving a V.A. hospital without getting the treatment he needed.

Kitty Genovese is Army Private First Class William Hamilton who stepped in front of a freight train after requesting admittance into the Palo Alto Veterans Hospital and being turned away.

Saving Kitty Genovese is about saving you and me, our mothers and fathers, our sisters and brothers, our children, our cousins and friends. It’s about saving all of us, each and every one, when we find ourselves in our darkest hours.

Saving Kitty Genovese is about forging the kind of world we truly wish to live in. And here’s the good news—we get to choose what kind of world that is.

Right now, one of our troops and veterans is sitting on the edge of their bed feeling hopeless, helpless, alone and uncared for.

Right now, one of our returning warriors needs to feel they matter, needs a way to move forward and to leave behind the mental and emotional scars derived from serving our country, from serving you.

Right now, someone’s brother or sister or father or mother is contemplating ending it all, with a gun or an electrical cord or a bottle of pills, because they can’t get the help they so desperately need.

And right now, with the cries for help loud and clear, we get to choose what kind of world we wish to live in.

It’s sad, but too often it seems that we have forgotten why we are truly here in this life. And the truth is that it’s not for ourselves, but for one another. In fact, it is the spirit of community and our allegiance to those around us that has allowed each and every one of us to enjoy a life of relative ease and opportunity in this world. This isn’t a lofty ideal, it’s the plain and simple truth and perhaps there is no better example of this than in our armed forces.

Ask any one of the brave men and women of our military what it was that allowed them to survive in combat and they will tell you; it wasn’t looking out for themselves, it was looking out for each other. And in fact, when we look closer it is clear that it wasn’t looking out for themselves that put them in harm’s way in the first place. It was looking out for us.

And it’s now our turn to return the favor.

This is the ideal—a commitment to the welfare of those around us—that will set us on a course of happiness, opportunity and well-being for all. For you, for me and for all the Kitty Genoveses of the world.

So this then is a call for us all to stand up, to lock arms and to do our duty—not as citizens, but as a human beings—and act.

As we hear the call for help from the brave men and women of our armed forces, don’t look to your left, don’t look to your right. Instead, look in the mirror. You are the one. It is you who we are all waiting for. It is you who must act.

You are the one with the power to choose what you stand for; what kind of example you set for your children, brothers, sisters and friends; what kind of world in which you wish to live.

I’m choosing to stand for Kitty Genovese. I’m choosing to stand for our troops and veterans. I’m choosing to stand for us all.

I hope you will stand with me.


Eric Walrabenstein is a former U.S. Army Infantry Officer and nationally-recognized teacher of yoga and mind/body health. He is the founder of Yoga Pura in Phoenix, Arizona and the creator of the BOOTSTRAP Armed Forces Stress-management Program, a free home-based program that combines modern stress-management principles with proven yoga techniques to help our returning warriors heal from post-traumatic stress and other psychological wounds. Troops and veterans can request free help at: Eric can be reached at [email protected]

Editor: Thaddeus Haas

Like elephant health & wellness on Facebook



About elephant journal

elephant journal is dedicated to "bringing together those working (and playing) to create enlightened society." We're about anything that helps us to live a good life that's also good for others, and our planet. >>> Founded as a print magazine in 2002, we went national in 2005 and then (because mainstream magazine distribution is wildly inefficient from an eco-responsible point of view) transitioned online in 2009. >>> elephant's been named to 30 top new media lists, and was voted #1 in the US on twitter's Shorty Awards for #green content...two years running. >>> Get involved: > Subscribe to our free Best of the Week e-newsletter. > Follow us on Twitter. Fan us on Facebook. > Write: send article or query. > Advertise. > Pay for what you read, help indie journalism survive and thrive—and get your name/business/fave non-profit on every page of Questions? Send to [email protected]


7 Responses to “Death, Indifference & the Yoga of Caring. ~ Eric Walrabenstein”

  1. VeryStupid says:

    I found comparing Kitty Genovese case with Marine Private and Army Specialist and who join the Army, Navy and Airforce voluntary is uncomprehending. Kitty Genovese did not choose to be attacked, raped and murdered.

    These Army, Navy and Airforce personnel choose to join the organisation, signed the contract, trained by the organisation and understand the consequences by going to the war zone. Knowing that everyone who come back from the war zone suffering PTSD and other mental illness also physical disability, then why so many people still want to join and be sent to the war zone???

  2. mrtbuck says:

    @Verystupid I think you miss the fact that the comparison is not about Kitty and the soldiers but us as bystanders and what we choose to do or not do when people need help

  3. VeryStupid says:

    Could you please advise what will you do in this case mrtbuck????

  4. Viviann says:

    I agree with you. VeryStupid missed the point of the letter completely. It's not so much about the service members who definitely do need our help, so much as it is about everybody else, and whether WE will just stand by and let these brothers and sisters, who put their very lives on the line for US, continue to suffer!

    Yes, they volunteered, and yes, they were trained in the ways of war, but even with all that training, there is NO way one can be truly prepared for the realities of war! In training, you don't really watch your comrades die in horrific ways, and you don't live in a constant state of fear for your life, and you don't have to worry that the person you have worked with will suddenly pull a gun and shoot you, or blow you and your buddies up! There is no way you can prepare for that!

    After living like that for 6 months to a year or more, you are suddenly transported back home, and expected to behave in a civilized manner, and forget the way you have had to live to protect yourself and your comrades! It just doesn't happen that easily!

    It is up to those of us who have lived our lives in safety here at home, because of these brave, sacrificing people and their families, to stand up and demand they get the treatment they deserve!! Let them know that we appreciate the service they gave to OUR country! Donate time to give them a safe place to express the fears they live with, and use innovative treatments to help them work their way out of the dark into the light! Therapies like Hypnotherapy, and Emotional Freedom Techniques (EFT) are being found to work very well. The government must be made aware, and begin to use these therapies. But most of all, WE, the people who have taken advantage of the peace and freedoms our service members have sacrificed for, must step up and be counted, and counted on to support our troups in any way they need!

  5. Dr Ruth Jones PhD says:

    In the UK there is an organisation called the Warrior Programme which amongst other things provides courses to help Veterans with PTSD. Is there something similar in the US? Peter Levine’s book: “In an Unspoken Voice” is excellent as is “War & the Soul” by Edward Tick. I’m not a Veteran but am involved with someone who is & reading these books has helped me understand better the trauma & in one way therefore help. Thank you so much for the article

  6. Qvintus says:

    “Kitty Genovese” are all the soldiers (women and men) who are raped while serving in the military, and then ostracized and victimized again when/if they report the crime.

    “Kitty Genovese” are all the civilian victims of war, terrorism and crimes everywhere, whenever those who should intervene fail to do so.

    Of course returning veterans of war — suffering from post-traumatic stress and suicidal thoughts & behaviour — should get all the help and support they need, but “Kitty Genovese” they usually are not really in the same way. Most veterans do get help, but it is a shame that so many still don't. Certainly, as a nation, it is easier to send people into war than to heal those coming back. In fact, a lot of the wounded, scarred and deeply changed veteran soldiers who make it back are rather often not very pleasant people that most other citizens would like to hang out with, which makes it all the more important that at least hospitals and other institutions are given enough resources, so they never have any excuse to act neglectfully or refuse health care.

    And I don't doubt that volunteers, churches and yoga communities can help, at some point in the process. Helping psychologically damaged soldiers is not about supporting the troops or the war effort. It's about helping humans in need. It's truly about ending the war.

  7. @USMCLife says:

    Very compelling article Eric, well written and very informative. I'm motivated to help, thank you for the reminder.