Thanksgiving: What our History Teacher didn’t Tell Us. ~ Maja Despot

Via elephant journal
on Nov 15, 2012
get elephant's newsletter
thanksgiving history jon stewart

The Real Thanksgiving.

For the most part, we think of Thanksgiving as a time of gratitude associated with happy Native Americans and Pilgrims sharing in a big feast together.

While that may have been the case in some instances, we tend to forget the dark and violent fate brought onto the Native American tribes by the arrival of European settlers.

The story of the real Thanksgiving is not all about smiles and turkey—although the turkeys don’t make it out alive either, of course!

The story starts around 1608, when a group of Native Americans trusted the European traders who had come to Massachusetts. When they decided to trade with the English they were taken as prisoners.

With a boat full of the Patuxet tribe, chained and bounded for slavery, the Englishmen sailed back to their home country. What they left behind was an epidemic of smallpox that wiped out the Patuxet that managed to escape being captured for enslavement.

Squanto was one of the Native Americans captured by the English. After 10 heartbreaking  years of enslavement in Spain, he made his way to England and negotiated for his freedom, and finally made his way back home. However, there was only more heartbreak awaiting him with the realization that his tribe and family had been completely wiped out by disease.

When the Pilgrims reached Massachusetts around 1620, Squanto was the only remaining Patuxet Indian. Regardless of the immense pain caused by his previous contact with the English people, Squanto found it in his heart to use the English he had learned during his time in Europe to negotiate a peace treaty between the Wampanoag nation and the Pilgrims. He also helped the Pilgrims survive their first winter in the new world. Squanto taught the new settlers how to plant their own corn and where the best fishing locations were. At the end of their first year in the new world, the Pilgrims held a large feast to honor the Wampanoags and Squanto.

However, good times soon turned to bad.

With word spreading throughout England of successes in the new world, Puritans began arriving in huge numbers. These settlers did not need the help of the Native Americans as the Pilgrims once did. They viewed the natives as savages with strange rituals and culture. Soon after their arrival, once communal lands were seized by both Puritan and British settlers.

The settlers captured those natives they deemed strong enough for slavery and killed off the rest. The children and grandchildren of those settlers and Native Americans that had once feasted together were now destroying each other.

The fighting continued on with many innocent Native Americans falling victim to the greed of the English settlers. Thanksgiving soon became a celebration for the victory over the Native Americans, whom the English viewed as heathen savages. The natives not only had their lives disrupted by disease but were exploited, enslaved and massacred by the thousands.

Historians estimate an 80-90 percent population decline after the arrival of the European settlers.

The reality of what happened during this time is a far stretch from the happy feast associated with Thanksgiving. The meaning of this post is not to ruin the holiday of Thanksgiving, but to give light to the reality of history, history that is sometimes left out of books in schools. In order to learn and progress, we must look back in time and accept the faults of our own country in hopes of never repeating them. We can no longer pretend that the the founders and first-comers of this country did not single-handedly destroy the natives.

Native Americans are a group of diverse tribes, all with their own unique cultures and traditions, but what brings them together is their violent demise.

They didn’t just contribute to American history in the form of Squanto’s generosity and legacy. Native Americans contributed in the areas of horticulture, science and medicine.

So, while you are enjoying some, er, Tofurkey and pumpkin pie this Thanksgiving, share the real story of Thanksgiving with those around you. Why? Not to be “a bummer.” Because, rather, awareness is the key to progress. It can be easy to overlook the contributions of the Native Americans in the earliest years of this country, but in remembering and being grateful for their contributions to the foundation of this country, we can use their stories as lessons in ahimsa and compassion.

Because we truly have so much to learn.


Maja Despot is a college student trying to figure out her place in the world, while making a positive impact. She’s a veggie, a blogger and mother of a feisty puppy named Minnie, whom she absolutely adores. She enjoys yoga, crafts and learning. Maja came to United States in 1997 from the former Yugoslavia. Six months later she was fluent in English. She’s currently studying Sociology at the University of Illinois at Chicago and hopes to use it to give back to the world.



Ed: Brianna Bemel



Like elephant Enlightened Society on Facebook.




About elephant journal

elephant journal is dedicated to "bringing together those working (and playing) to create enlightened society." We're about anything that helps us to live a good life that's also good for others, and our planet. >>> Founded as a print magazine in 2002, we went national in 2005 and then (because mainstream magazine distribution is wildly inefficient from an eco-responsible point of view) transitioned online in 2009. >>> elephant's been named to 30 top new media lists, and was voted #1 in the US on twitter's Shorty Awards for #green content...two years running. >>> Get involved: > Subscribe to our free Best of the Week e-newsletter. > Follow us on Twitter. Fan us on Facebook. > Write: send article or query. > Advertise. > Pay for what you read, help indie journalism survive and thrive—and get your name/business/fave non-profit on every page of Questions? Send to


15 Responses to “Thanksgiving: What our History Teacher didn’t Tell Us. ~ Maja Despot”

  1. Nail says:

    What a great post. Love it!

  2. For real says:

    Every single culture should apologize for their enslaving of and taking advantage of neighboring people's they have invaded. All the way back to feudal times. Just think of all the cultures that were destroyed because of these invasions and subsequent enslavement. Just think of all the Africans sold by their own people to European slave traders. Never to see their own lands again 🙁

  3. Rich K says:


    I love you and the work you do. I’m excited to see where your life takes you!

    Peace and Love,


  4. eleanor says:

    This topic has been up for much discussion between my seven year old son and I this week. After briefly summarizing the events that shaped our America to him (contrary to many things they discuss in his public school), I concluded that I have a book by Howard Zinn that, when ready and willing he is welcome to read and own. He requested to take it for his night time reading after I read aloud the first few paragraphs. I strongly believe that if we teach our children the real, hard to digest, cold truth, we are creating a world of knowledge and understanding and, therefore, the willingness to be better; to strive for compassion and community. All of the lies we were fed in standardized publications can be erased if we hold true to our children. Our task in this life may have been to cypher out the wrongs and promote the rights so that the future can be well despite all of our mistakes. I know for a fact that I will openly admit my personal mistakes to my son. He is worth it. And so is the world he leaves for all who have it after him.

  5. Peaceful Warrior says:

    Eleanor, thank you for reading and sharing the story of your son. It takes courage to be completely transparent, and it is very honorable that you are showing him both sides of the story. I completely agree, with teaching children the truth we can strive for passion. Awareness is key to progress, thank you so much for your comment again!

  6. Peaceful Warrior says:

    Thanks Rich!

  7. Peaceful Warrior says:

    Thanks 🙂

  8. Peaceful Warrior says:

    For real, I completely agree with you. There are so many dark sides of history that are overlooked and glossed over especially in school. Only in college did I finally get to hear the dark reality of what happened. The first step is to accept responsibility and stop acting like the dark history of these people doesn't still impact them today. Thank you for reading and your comment!

  9. […] Thanksgiving is refuge, it is family, it is a too-rare time when family comes together and sits down and keeps it simple. […]

  10. […] Thankgiving: What Your History Teacher Didn’t Tell You. ~ Maja Despot […]

  11. […] Thankgiving: What Your History Teacher Didn’t Tell You. ~ Maja Despot ( […]

  12. […] Thankgiving: What Your History Teacher Didn’t Tell You. ~ Maja Despot ( […]

  13. […] with people you love and have a Happy Thanksgiving! […]

  14. […] Simms, Lacy Ramunno, Sara Crolick, Amy Cushing, Wendy Keslick, Rebecca Schwarz, Elysha Anderson, Maja Despot, Anne Clendening, Olivia Gray, Christa Angelo, Thandiwe Ogbonna, Stephanie Vessely, Caroline […]