3.3

Finding Balance: Holistic Medicine, Common Sense & the Dangers of Pseudoscience.

TruthOut.org/Flickr

One of the most common, universal and cross-cultural overarching human philosophical ideals is the importance of balance.

Taoists cite the yin and yang, Buddhists are reminded to seek “Middle Way,” Confucius venerated the “Doctrine of the Mean,” the Hermetic mystics eulogized Hermes Trismegistus’s insistence that “As above, so below”—an elucidation mirrored by the scientific observation of countless examples of congruity between microcosm and macrocosm. Nature and evolution do virtually all they do in the service of maintaining a natural equilibrium and things go very wrong in the human body when our balances are disturbed.

The pursuit of balance is an admirable human endeavor, and while it’s sometimes overlooked, the seeking of intellectual balance is as important to a fulfilling life as the physical and spiritual harmony.

Being intellectually inflexible and intractable in beliefs is almost never good. For instance, there’s a tendency among my friends and colleagues interested in alternative medicine and treatment options to presume that any alternative treatment is healthier, safer and/or more efficacious than the “Western Medicine.” It’s a conclusion that’s comparable to the one made by my friends and colleagues who are absolutists about Western Medicine and dismiss all alternative treatments as nonsense.

That sort of unbalanced perspective is not just wrongheaded; it can be downright dangerous and sometimes even deadly. Three examples of useless and even dangerous pseudoscience (something that’s couched like an effective, reasonable, logical or scientific theory but isn’t) come to mind immediately. Those are:

 

Homeopathy

A holistic approach to one’s well-being isn’t only important, it’s vital for true healthiness–but homeopathy should not be part of a holistic regimen.

Homeopathy was created, or at least named, in 1796 by Samuel Hahnemann, based on his belief that all disease was the result of malevolent “miasms”. To treat these miasm-engendered diseases, Hahnemann employed the philosophy of “like cures like.” The basic claim is that a substance that causes the symptoms of disease in healthy people will cure similar symptoms in sick people. The process involves finding a substance that actually causes the symptoms of or causes mirrored symptoms in healthy people similar to those suffered by the ill person. Then, that substance would be diluted down many thousands (even millions) of times and administered to the afflicted. 

For example, if someone overdosed on opium, this practice would advise a speck of opium be diluted in water or alcohol past the point that any trace of it remained with the resulting solution being administered to the afflicted. Or if someone were suffering from a fever, a similarly diluted solution of some herb that caused fever-like symptoms should be administered. The more diluted the substance, homeopathy holds, the more effective its treatment potential. As most homeopathic solutions have literally no trace of their diluted substance, the argument is that the water retains the molecular “memory” of that substance. 

Of course, human experience, seeming common sense and all of the available evidence suggests that this isn’t the case. And for that we can be thankful, because if the water retained the memory of whatever substance, its memories of millennia of human and animal waste, natural poisons, radioactive elements and other carcinogens, thousands of different varieties of pollution and caustic toxic waste would remain as well.

 

Fluoride 

It’s certainly easy to understand the widespread apprehension inspired by any governmental body of adding chemicals to the water supply. However, the addition of fluoride, according to all available evidence, scientific and anecdotal, is apparently not something that should worry us. In fact, fluoridated water has proved a boon to us, or at least to our teeth.

The contention forwarded by the anti-fluoridation camp is that fluoride is a dangerous, poisonous chemical and (the most common conspiracy theory holds) the government adds it to keep the population docile. However, there’s no evidence that this is the case, either scientifically or anecdotally; no study on the subject finds any ill-effects at all from fluoridated water. Nor do we find that the populations of cities without fluoridation are any more spry or healthy than their counterparts anywhere else. 

 

Immunization

The anti-immunization movement has been one of the most destructive pseudoscientific health hazards of the last few decades. In 1999, the vaccine preservative thimerosal was phased out of production from all European and American vaccines. Although there is no evidence that thimerosal was at all dangerous, it was removed from vaccines just in case due to concerns (unsupported by evidence) that it contributed to climbing autism rates. Unfortunately, that attempt to soothe public concerns backfired and a vocal minority became convinced that thimerosal must indeed be dangerous.

The hype drummed up regarding the link between vaccines and autism has resulted in a dangerous trend of children going unvaccinated. Thousands of kids are getting sick and many dying from diseases that had literally disappeared from our country before the immunization “controversy.” Perhaps the most troubling feature of this trend—babies too young to be vaccinated are now dying from pertussis and other illnesses such as measles borne by children whose parents didn’t vaccinate them. The removal of thimerosal from vaccines has had absolutely no effect on the rising rates of autism and unvaccinated children are absolutely as likely as those who get their vaccines to develop it. 

 

Common Sense Holistic Health Solutions and Drum Circle Therapeutics

The point of mentioning those things isn’t to bash on alternative treatments—just the opposite. Faddish and/or pseudoscientific treatments or health scares that are patently and demonstrably false and dangerous like anti-fluoridation campaigns, homeopathy and anti-immunization movements do more harm to legitimate, helpful alternative treatment regimens than the most cynical skeptic ever could.

The problem with a total adherence to Western medicine, it’s often been pointed out, is that it generally focuses on symptoms rather than root causes. A holistic approach to medicine and health is one that incorporates the physical, psychological and spiritual components of comprehensive wellness. For the physical, a traditional medical solution is often just “what the doctor ordered,” so to speak. For instance, I used to get really nasty bouts of strep throat, and based on my experience, antibiotics are a really, really great to alleviate that. To treat the strep I got to a doctor, to prevent the strep in the first place, I look to alternative. 

My particular alternative is the drum circle. That may not sound as “traditional” an alternative treatment as acupuncture, deep tissue massage, yoga or the targeted use of supplements, but it’s surprisingly cathartic, and has a variety of positive effects on me. Grabbing a djembe drum and joining a group of friends or strangers for the finding of a shared rhythm that belongs to the group as a whole and everybody in it individually is more refreshing for me than a hot shower and a cold beer. 

I imagine it’s something one has to experience to fully appreciate, but being a part of a circle that has comfortably found its place becomes a sort of animated, group meditation. And no doubt you’re already aware of meditation’s tremendous capacity for de-stressing—they’re even starting to teach it in college. Beyond that, there are the less glamorous but no less important benefits of mild exercise, improved mood and the satisfaction of companionship.

That’s my mental and spiritual medicine, and one I wholeheartedly suggest. Whatever yours is, though—incorporating that with the often astounding medical advancements made available in recent years is precisely the sort of balance that leads to a longer, healthier and happier life.

 

 

Author: Andrew Heikkila

Editor: Emily Bartran

Photo: truthout.org/Flickr

You must be logged in to post a comment. Create an account.

Padma Kadag Apr 1, 2016 7:20am

The only time my children saw a doctor was for athletic physicals. We had a classically trained Homeopath. Yes they were vaccinated. This fantasy of being in "balance" is just that, a fantasy.

andrewheikkila32 Mar 29, 2016 8:25am

To respond to Dan, Mary, Rad, Kelly, and Cara:

I've provided links that support my claims:
-https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeopathy
-(sources cited within include: http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1467
-https://www.sciencemag.org/news/sifter/homeopathy-ineffective-study-confirms
-http://www.livescience.com/37123-fluoridation.html
-http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/111/3/674.full
-http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2014/10/there-is-no-alternative-medicine/379342/

Among others…. to say that I don't support my claims is a little disingenuous–on the other hand, there wasn't a commentor besides Dan was kind enough to dispute his or her claims with a source. So for anybody on here claiming that I'm misinformed or uneducated on the topic, I've done my research and presented it all right here in this article. The burden of proof is now on you.

I welcome healthy debate, but I know inevitably it will devolve to name-calling and insults on my intelligence. so get it out of your system, go ahead and call me an idiot or accuse me of being brainwashed or a pawn to big pharma–but until you provide some warrant to legitimize your claims that homeopathy works, that fluoride is harming populations, and that avoiding vaccines shows more net benefit than getting them, all you're doing is stating your own opinions (besides Dan).

Nevertheless, I appreciate you all reading the article and hope to see some sources in further responses 🙂 much love to all

Lori Mar 28, 2016 1:49pm

You seem to be listening to big money (pharma) rhetoric and not doing much research. People who make the choice to forgo vaccines or selectively vaccinate are highly educated on the subject and most would not state that the “fear” of autism is their main reasoning. Have you read anything about the unnatural way that diseases enter the body through vaccination? Or about how there has been a huge rise in autoimmune diseases since the introduction of vaccines? More people are suffering and dying slowly but that doesn’t get addressed in your article.

Read The Best Articles of March
You voted with your hearts, comments, views, and shares.
CLICK TO SEE WHO WON

Andrew Heikkila

Andrew Heikkila is a writer from Boise, ID who likes to focus on the intersections between the body, the spirit, the mind, and technology and culture. Follow him on Twitter at AndyO_TheHammer.