Does Yoga Kill? ~ Timothy McCall

Via on Mar 20, 2013

In the little over one year that New York Times science reporter William Broad has been covering yoga, he has dropped one bombshell after another: Yoga could make you fat, the entire discipline started as a sex cult, and, of course, the claim that garnered worldwide publicity—practicing yoga is dangerous to life and limb.

Most shocking of all, his 2012 book The Science of Yoga tied yoga to hundreds of strokes per year. His “lowball estimate” was that 15 yoga practitioners annually in the United States “lay dead after wounds to their vertebral arteries resulted in brain injuries serious enough to kill.”

In my recent article, Man Bites Downward-Facing Dog, I documented Broad’s disturbing pattern of sensationalistic reporting. Again and again he has made bold, counterintuitive assertions about yoga, which have succeeded in bringing attention to himself and his book, but which, as I demonstrated, fail to hold up under scientific scrutiny.

Unexpected for a science writer of his stature (he’s shared in two Pulitzer Prizes), no extraordinary evidence backs his extraordinary claims. And that holds especially true for his claim that yoga causes deadly strokes—the emotional linchpin of his yoga-wrecks-your-body arguments.

Broad labeled a number of poses “X-rated,” including Shoulderstand, Plow, Cobra and Wheel. The extreme neck positions in these postures, he warned, could stretch and potentially rupture the vertebral arteries, linguini-like blood vessels that run along the spinal bones in the neck. Strokes due to vertebral artery tears are uncommon, but are known to occur, for example, when an elderly woman drops her head back into a hairdresser’s sink for a shampoo.

Broad cited an estimate that among the general public there are 1.5 such strokes per year per 100,000 people.

Since, as Broad admitted, no scientific studies have ever examined the question of how common such yoga-induced strokes are, he got creative. First off, he assumed—without evidence—that yoga practitioners would have the same 1.5 per 100,000 rate of vertebral artery injuries as the general population (while suggesting the likelihood of a higher rate due to all the neck movements).

With 20 million practitioners in the U.S., that’s 300 strokes per year. Assuming a five percent mortality rate, he calculated the yearly death toll would be 15. But if yoga practitioners have the same stroke rate as people who don’t do yoga, that means on net yoga caused zero strokes.

Using the logic Broad employed, if there are 16,000 cases of food poisoning per 100,000 people, every year yoga is tied to 320,000 episodes of the dreaded and potentially deadly intestinal malady.

 

The Smoking Gun

In pursuing the yoga-stroke connection, Broad seemed to have found his smoking gun in 2009. “Now a major survey done by yoga professionals had documented the threat,” he wrote. “The respondents said they had witnessed four cases, in other words, they knew of four occasions in which yoga’s extreme bending and contortions had resulted in some degree of brain damage.”

But the scientific article reporting the survey’s results, published in the International Journal of Yoga Therapy, tells a different story.

The authors, a team based at New York’s Columbia College of Physicians and Surgeons, confessed that they, “neglected, however, to remind the respondents that answers should be based on injuries resulting from yoga practice. Instead, many answers described serious injuries or chronic conditions that prompted people to take yoga. Often it was unclear whether injuries cited had resulted from Yoga or from some other source.”

To resolve the ambiguity, my colleague Roger Cole, Ph.D., contacted study co-author Susan Genis, RYT, Esq., who did the data analysis. Here’s how she responded:

“William Broad misstates the information we presented. None of the survey responses gave a specific instance of having experienced or having seen a student experience a stroke as a result of yoga practice.”

 

The Yogi’s Quest for Truth

While continuing to trumpet the dangers of yoga, Broad appears to have resigned himself to a less-than-enthusiastic reception to his work from many in the yoga world. “Some yoga practitioners will surely see my analysis as unconvincing. That’s okay,” he wrote in a recent Times article that asserted that yoga is “remarkably dangerous—for men.”

One of the foundations of the serious practice of yoga—and by this I mean much more than just the physical postures which are Broad’s main focus—is satya, Sanskrit for truth. Serious yogis try to cut through illusions, and seek to know, as they call it, “what is,” even when digesting that truth is painful.

While they don’t always succeed, and are subject to the same foibles as everyone else, they take seriously the quest to see reality clearly. That is why, in part due to Broad’s work, the yoga world is by and large welcoming the discussion about how the practice can be done more safely.*

The other reason, of course, is that ahimsa, non-harming, sits alongside satya as the foundation of the entire practice.

Dedicated yogis recognize that, despite Broad’s own yoga practice and all the research he did for the book—and the many parts of the story he gets right—there remain gaps in his understanding. What galls many of them is that he makes assertions like his stroke claims that are just plain wrong with the zeal of a cub reporter exposing vicious corporate malfeasance, all under the imprimatur of the New York Times and with the added heft of the oft-mentioned Pulitzer Prizes.

Not all yogis understand the weakness of the scientific support for some of his claims, but they know in their gut when they hear something about the field they’ve dedicated their lives to that isn’t true to their experience.

 

Engaging Truth

The conflict between satya and a good read appears to be at the root of Broad’s credibility problem.

If a writer wanted to create an attention-getting story on yoga injuries, in addition to exaggerating the problem and including a few heart-wrenching stories, it would be best to pretend that no one was talking about it. Broad quoted an Indian swami, dead for almost 20 years and largely unknown in the U.S., who once said that yoga is as safe as mother’s milk—as if among modern teachers this were the party line.

If the incidence of injuries is undramatically low, the engaging writer should avoid comparisons to similar activities. Only after being criticized for the latter did Broad recently acknowledge that the injury rate is higher for golf.

But yoga injuries are qualitatively different he warned, and for that argument, he once again trotted out the stroke risk.

To bolster his case, he listed several people whose deaths might have been caused by yoga including this one: “In Los Angeles in 2004, Sita White, 43, a British heiress and a favorite of gossip columnists, collapsed and died in a yoga class. The question is why.”

What Broad neglected to mention is that she wasn’t doing yoga at the time. According to eyewitnesses and media reports, White collapsed and died while students were filing in and putting down their mats.

Had Sita White died 15 minutes later, presumably Broad would have detailed just how yoga had done her in. This is one of the risks of relying on anecdotal data: it’s easy to confuse a temporal association with causation.

Of note, the few stroke cases he described in his book spanned more than 30 years—one suspects he needed to go that far back because there weren’t that many good stories to choose from.

 

Does Yoga Actually Decrease the Risk of Strokes?

One possibility that Broad never considered is that practicing yoga might actually decrease the rate of vertebral artery strokes. Research has documented that people with tight muscles are more likely to have inflexible arteries.

Thus, ironically, regularly practicing the very poses he deemed verboten like Cobra and Shoulderstand—if they are done appropriately—might reduce the risk of vertebral artery strokes by gradually increasing the pliability of these blood vessels, making them more resistant to tearing with sudden movement or accidental impact.

The bigger picture is that vertebral artery strokes make up less than one percent of all strokes. Practicing yoga—via such documented benefits as improving blood pressure, reducing stress hormone and cholesterol levels, damping inflammation and thinning the blood—likely reduces the overall incidence of all kinds of strokes, as well as heart attacks and a host of other conditions.

Comedian Stephen Colbert famously coined the term truthiness to describe the work of politicians and journalists who cherry-pick, massage, and selectively report information to fit the narrative they’re crafting.

The truth, on the other hand, is often complicated, nuanced, and doesn’t always make a great story. And it is precisely that satya—subtle, interpenetrating, endlessly unfolding—that yogis are after.

 

*To further the discussion of this topic, Yoga U, an online educational resource, will broadcast free of charge from April 10-14, 2013 a telesummit on yoga injuries, featuring Timothy McCall, Judith Hanson Lasater, Loren Fishman, Roger Cole, Julie Gudmestad, Leslie Kaminoff and other leading yoga teachers. 

 

Timothy McCallBoard-certified internist Timothy McCall, MD, teaches yoga therapy seminars worldwide. He is the medical editor of Yoga Journal, the best selling author of Yoga as Medicine and has managed to survive 18 years of yoga practice. He can be found on the web at DrMcCall.com.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Like elephant yoga on Facebook.

Ed: Bryonie Wise

(Source: storiented.blogspot.com via Zoey on Pinterest)

 

About elephant journal

elephant journal is dedicated to "bringing together those working (and playing) to create enlightened society." We're about anything that helps us to live a good life that's also good for others, and our planet. >>> Founded as a print magazine in 2002, we went national in 2005 and then (because mainstream magazine distribution is wildly inefficient from an eco-responsible point of view) transitioned online in 2009. >>> elephant's been named to 30 top new media lists, and was voted #1 in the US on twitter's Shorty Awards for #green content...two years running. >>> Get involved: > Subscribe to our free Best of the Week e-newsletter. > Follow us on Twitter Fan us on Facebook. > Write: send article or query. > Advertise. > Pay for what you read, help indie journalism survive and thrive. Questions? info elephantjournal com

5,275 views

Like this article? Leave a tip!

(We use PayPal but you don't need an account with PayPal.)

Elephriends - Mindful Affiliates

16 Responses to “Does Yoga Kill? ~ Timothy McCall”

  1. Lucille says:

    He is right: yoga is killing my ego and though scary at first, there is no greater freedom.

  2. Bernie says:

    Yoga saved my life – and I think people like Broad will do anything to get publicity, including damaging the reputation of a healthy practice that has improved people’s lives for well over 2500 years!

  3. Yogi Chuckananda says:

    Having read Broads book with out prejudice, I must agree with Dr. McCall that his research is sorely skewed towards his own biased views. Yoga is of so much benefit to so many that a lot of financially interested groups must want to smear it's reputation. Perhaps someone could write an expose on Broads compensation for writing this book! Somehow, I have been practicing yoga for more than 45 years, and I feel much better when I practice.

  4. I suspect that Broad's findings do not have much effect on the general public's appreciation or interest in yoga. Most folks will have heard more about a friend benefitting from a practice than will be aware of his work. However, it is to Dr. McCall's and his colleagues credit that they douse man made fires before they burn the forest.

  5. shiva says:

    Thanks Dr. Mccall. Your detailed explanation is reassuring to people like me who practice asana but have very little knowledge of human anatomy/health.

  6. paul says:

    Thank you Dr. McCall for keeping after this. I stopped taking the book seriously when in his chronology of yoga he leaves out the atharva veda but frames tantra as being exclusively about magic-powers and sex. Doing a search on google books, the terms "veda" "vedic" "upanishad" all "returned no results" (it does search pages not in the preview).

  7. Joe Sparks says:

    Please check out Michealle Edward, author of YogAlign. Her website is http://www.manayoga.com some of the yoga poses are actually hurting people. We need to look further into this. Michaelle has done a good job. See for yourself.

    • Napongo says:

      That is such a strange blanket statement. How can you make generalizations like that? Of course you can get injured from yoga, but to make a generalized statement that "some of the yoga poses are actually hurting people" sounds like just more of the same fear-mongering that William Broad has made himself known for.

      Michelle Edwards and helpers (as you may be?) are posting about Yogalign in pretty much any article about yoga injuries. If your intent is to contribute to the debate, please refrain from making generic, unfounded statements, and be specific. If your intent is to advertise Yogaalign, please go through regular marketing channels for that. Comments are for discussion contributions, not for advertising. Thanks!

  8. John Doyle says:

    I was the one who performed CPR on Sita White and I am a medical doctor. She collapsed right in front of me before class began as people were putting down their mats well before class began. My understanding was that she died of a pulmonary embolism. I seriously doubt her yoga practice had anything to do with this tragedy. In fact, immobilization (as in a hospitalized patient for example) is one risk factor, which is the exact opposite of a yoga asana practice.

  9. lisa says:

    thanks for this great article. I printed out your other one to share with my yoga students and will share this one with them as well. my blanket statement. for the day.. forget yoga… SITTING ON YOUR ASS can wreck the body… and doing ANYthing mindlessly can kill you. (texting and walking down the street anyone? watch out for cars.)

    Broad did a great service to the yoga world. he opened up conversation and awareness. Otherwise, he was all about sensationalistic articles to sell books.

  10. vicmccolm says:

    I have been following the back and forth between all of these folks for the last year and here's my request….

    There are a lot of practitioners who are put off and confused by the nastiness of the yoga injuries debate. The whole thing seems very unyogic and it would be so good for the community if everyone mentioned in the above article could sit down together and have a dialogue on the issue of yoga injuries and yoga safety in general, rather than pointing fingers.

    The most disappointing thing about the way this debate is being handled is that both sides (Broad vs. McCall, Cole, Fishman, et al) have mostly remained silent until it was time to sell something. We didn't hear from Broad again until Dec when it was time for his paperback to come out. And we are now conveniently hearing from McCall and crew just in time for the next Telesummit on Yoga Injuries (they held the same event last year – its free to listen in, but if you want the transcripts to study or share with your students, you have to pay).

    Both sides are making money from keeping this issue hot and keeping people on edge about who's right and who's wrong. Meanwhile, there is substantive work that can be done to make sure that everyone has a safe practice, and that can move our beloved community forward. Not everyone "knows" that injuries can be caused by ego, or what poses they need to avoid due to a contraindicated medical condition, heck most teachers don't even know how to advise their students on the latter.

    There are several points in the debate that both sides agree on – need for better teacher training, as an example – that we could all work together to improve. Why don't we direct all of this energy towards something positive, rather than continuing to put each other down over an issue that is quite serious and affects many peoples' practice?

    • Actually, both Roger Cole and I responded almost immediately after the release of the How Yoga Can Wreck Your Body book excerpt in the Sunday Times Magazine, not because we stood to make any money, but simply because we felt the inaccuracies needed to be addressed. And while criticizing Broad, I also wrote in that first article that I thought he had provided a service by highlighting the issue of yoga injuries. But when I read the recent Times article that declared that yoga was "remarkably dangerous for men," it was for me the straw that broke the camel's back, and I put in dozens of hours of research into writing articles published on blogs that pay nothing. Only after I'd written Man Bites Downward-Facing Dog did I connect with Yoga U about the possibility linking its publication with a rebroadcast (and significant expansion) of the telesummit, which, whatever its limitations, still has something like 10 hours of material you can listen to for free.

  11. Tomasz Goetel [Hot Yoga] says:

    Well said, Mr. McCall! Thank you very much for writing this.

  12. NickB says:

    Controversy over chiropractic manipulation causing such strokes has been around for a while (e.g.: http://www.musmed.com/Neurology%20Editorial.pdf and http://odsarti05.webs.com/diseccion%20review.pdf which also mentions yoga) but a recent large study seems to rule out the risk: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/pmc22711… It seems likely that carefully practiced, well taught yoga would also not have a much hightened risk, allowing for other factors.

Leave a Reply