Lovin’ the Wrong Foods: WWGD? (What Would Gurumayi Do?) by Dr. Sara Gottfried, MD

Via Sara Gottfried, MD
on May 8, 2011
get elephant's newsletter

It’s time to stop the madness with weight and food. Women especially aspire to thinness and this leads to distorted relationship to eating. We seek peace with food, yet we’re going about it all wrong. We starve ourselves on a new diet each Monday, and then binge by the weekend. Eighty percent of American women are on a diet, and you can bet that millions are planning their next diet, the latest program to drop pounds effortlessly. Yet 98% of diets fail. We progress to surgery – lapbands or liposuction. We inject hormones like junkies such as hCG, human Chorionic Gonadotropin, a hormone of pregnancy. Madness.

Who gets it right? Gurumayi Chidvilasananda, the Siddha Yoga guru popularized by Elizabeth Gilbert in Eat Pray Love. Gurumayi gets me to reframe the role of food in my life, and to observe how food could best serve me and others.

For many, reframe starts with identifying your default pattern. Your reach for chocolate, sugar, coffee, the latest haute cupcake, fine wine. Your attachment to a particular weight. Your attachment to certain restaurants and certain brands of food.

“I only drink Vanille Sencha from Mariage Freres!” protested one patient recently, when I asked about caffeine intake and her lousy sleep.

Perhaps you romanticize food. I used to. Well, I still do much of the time, but I rarely act on it. I wake up thinking about where I want to go for lunch with a friend, or which new restaurant I want to check out with my husband for date night. I peruse menus and get caught up; I get attached to certain outcomes. I plan what I’ll eat. I plan the emotion that I want to accompany the food: madly in love, delightedly connected via dialogue with a great friend, surprised and inspired by new heights of culinary artfulness.

For many, delight in food may devolve into compulsion. Do you compulsively eat certain foods, or drink Vanille Sencha, or compulsively weigh yourself each morning?

Gurumayi has this to say about discipline around food, in her book, Yoga of Discipline.

The sense of taste holds everyone in its thrall. For the sake of the tongue, there is no telling what a person will do. Everything that lives must eat. But this very process of eating can take you to heaven or hell. Eating can make you ignorant or it can help you realize the Truth. Depending on what food you eat, you will have a mind filled with agitation or with tranquility. The food you eat determines what you feel, what you think, and what you do. Understanding the value and the nature of food itself is just as important as the process of eating. Discipline in eating must be practiced with every bite.

Women and Food. Women and Weight. It’s BIG. I agree with Geneen Roth that it’s about something bigger than the lesser topics at hand of food and eating – it’s about divinity. Your hunger for food might be hunger for something larger, such as God, or a Higher Power, or Flow. Call it whatever you’d like. Food and weight just might be a vehicle to our Divine Self, Authentic or True Self — our sense of integrity, aliveness and connected wholeness. True Self is your path to a right-sized body, not stronger will power. Well, more specifically True Self and a right-sized False Self, which develops from how you’ve complied to external rules, such as how your body is supposed to look, how much you are expected to eat, the social codes of eating, food and body image.

Winnecott believed that every person is a hybrid of True and False Self, and your False Self hangs out somewhere along a continuum from healthy to pathological. In other words, your division of True and False Self may be at the root of your difficulty with food, if you have one.

I like to use this construct of True and False Self to excavate information about what food would best serve you. We want to use your divine intelligence to discern what to eat, and “eat with restraint and reverence,” according to Baba Muktananda, the predecessor of Gurumayi. He adds: “As you take medicine in a measured dose, take food in a measured, frugal quantitiy.”

Put another way, hunger for food has the potential to be alchemical, a yearning for something bigger than the parameters of your current reach. A hunger for Truth. What is your truth as it relates to food? We all respond differently to this question. After years of intestinal issues, I’m coming to the rather unwelcome conclusion that my truth may be this: a vegan diet would serve me better. It would help me transit time. It may provide my mind with greater tranquility. I’ve already kicked sugar, gluten and alcohol. Perhaps meat and animal-products are next?

Is it crazy hard for you to give up the goods —  the sugar, the coffee, the expensive wine? WWGD?

If restraint is a challenge, you must work on it, says Gurumayi. You must transcend the desire for food that is bad for you.

Easy for Gurumayi, perhaps. If that sounds like an impossible goal, consider one of the 12-step programs for food such as Food Addicts or Overeaters Anonymous. To paraphrase 12-step, addiction to bad food, or to excessive quantity, is a medical problem with a spiritual solution.

Please share your truth, in the comments section. And stop the madness with compulsive eating and weighing. Start your recovery today.


About Sara Gottfried, MD

I believe in evidence-based ancient wisdom. I believe in eating your leafy greens rather than popping synthetic pills. I believe in Ayurveda and integrative medicine. I believe in botanical therapies over synthetic hormones. I believe you deserve to feel sexy, ripe and delicious. I believe in tending your flame. I believe that proactively managing and optimizing your health is your divine responsibility and a path to personal power. I’m a mother suspicious of processed sugar and a yogini hotly pursuing lithe, lean lusciousness. I’m committed to deep green, organic living. I’m a scholar and a seeker of truth, vitality, hormonal balance, sacred balance, spirituality and divine self-actualization. I’m Sara Gottfried, MD and you can find me at my website or love my Facebook page.


8 Responses to “Lovin’ the Wrong Foods: WWGD? (What Would Gurumayi Do?) by Dr. Sara Gottfried, MD”

  1. AMO says:

    Ahhhh. Such a peaceful lovely way to approach the issue. I ask people, are you eating more than your fair share? Are you eating foods that nourish your body, and also the planet and the beings who live here? Do you eat food that has been prepared with love by people who like what they do? If you can say yes to these questions then you are eating well….

  2. Jen says:

    I find this article to be strange. In one breath you are saying that we should stop obsessing over our weight, and in another breath, you are saying that we should carefuly monitor our food intake and cut out many foods from our diets. The mentality of "I can't ever eat sugar or have a glass of wine" leads to obsession with food. Obsession with food leads to eating disorders. I am not really clear on your intention for writing this….

  3. Kapha-Pitta says:

    Says one Vata, quoting another Vata.
    Not everyone can be a Vata.

    I am SOOOO tired of the exhaltaion of Vata in all things Yoga and "Health" related.
    Go have a sesame oil-dashmula basti, already, and come back down to Earth!

  4. Just posted to "Popular Lately" on the Elephant Yoga homepage.

  5. Ashley says:

    My struggle with food is enormous. The restricting, then the binging, all because of an attachment to an ideal image and number on a scale. This added some perspective to my compulsiveness when it comes to food, so thank you. I needed to read this.

  6. Carlos Lucero says:

    Anyone know where is Gurumayi now ? Namasté

  7. […] I first heard my guru, Gurumayi Chidvilasananda, say those words in one of her public talks, I wanted to take them to heart. I really did. […]